Question 1
2 marksA student acidifies a solution with dilute sulfuric acid, instead of dilute hydrochloric acid, before adding barium chloride solution.
Explain why this is a mistake.
Model answer
Sulfuric acid contains sulfate ions. These would react with barium chloride to form a white precipitate of barium sulfate even if the sample contained no sulfate ions, so the result would be meaningless.
Explanation
The acid used in a test must not contain the ion being tested for. That is why hydrochloric acid is used for the sulfate test and nitric acid is used for the halide test.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
sulfuric acid contains / adds sulfate ions
-
1 mark
so a white precipitate (of barium sulfate) would form whether or not the sample contained sulfate ions
allow gives a false positive result