Question 1
2 marksSodium chloride can be represented by a ball and stick model.
Give two limitations of using a ball and stick model to represent the structure of sodium chloride.
Model answer
The sticks suggest that each ion is joined to particular neighbours by a bond, but ionic bonding is electrostatic attraction acting in all directions. Also, the balls are spread out with large gaps, but in reality the ions are packed closely together.
Explanation
Ball and stick models are useful for showing the 3D arrangement of ions, but the sticks and spaces are not real. A limitation is a way in which the model differs from the real substance.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
the sticks suggest bonds between particular pairs of ions / ionic bonding acts in all directions, not along sticks
max 2; any two from the list; allow sticks are not real
-
1 mark
the ions are shown far apart but are really packed closely together / touching
allow gaps between ions are exaggerated
-
1 mark
it shows only a small part of the giant lattice
-
1 mark
the relative sizes of the ions may not be shown correctly
allow does not show that chloride ions are larger than sodium ions