Question 1
2 marksBen wants to bisect angle PQR using only a ruler and a pair of compasses.
Here are his steps.
Step 1: With the compass point on Q, make an arc that crosses QP at X and QR at Y.
Step 2: With the compass point on X, make an arc of radius 5 cm inside the angle.
Step 3: With the compass point on Y, make an arc of radius 7 cm that crosses the first arc at Z.
Step 4: Use the ruler to join Q to Z with a straight line, extended beyond Z.
Ben's line QZ does not bisect angle PQR.
Explain the mistake Ben has made and how he should correct it.
Model answer
Ben's mistake: in step 2 he uses radius 5 cm but in step 3 he uses radius 7 cm, so ZX is not equal to ZY.
Correction: the arcs centred on X and on Y must have the same radius, e.g. use 5 cm for both. Then Z is the same distance from X and Y, and QZ bisects the angle.
Explanation
QX = QY because both points are on the same arc centred on Q. If ZX = ZY as well, triangles QXZ and QYZ are congruent (SSS), so angle XQZ = angle YQZ. With radii 5 cm and 7 cm, ZX is not equal to ZY, so Z is not on the bisector.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for: the arcs centred on X and Y have different radii (5 cm and 7 cm)
Accept 'he changed the radius in step 3' or 'step 2 and step 3 use different radii'. Do not accept 'the radii are too big' or 'step 1 is wrong'.
-
1 mark
B1 for: the arcs from X and Y must have the same radius (so that Z is the same distance from X and from Y)
Accept e.g. 'use 5 cm for both arcs' or 'use 7 cm for both' or 'keep the compasses the same width'. The reason in brackets is not required.