The big idea
The periodic table took many years to develop. Early scientists arranged the elements by atomic weight, because protons, neutrons and electrons had not been discovered. Their tables had problems, which Mendeleev overcame by leaving gaps and changing the order where the properties did not fit. When the elements he predicted were found, and later when atomic numbers and isotopes were understood, his approach was shown to be right.
Early tables
Before protons, neutrons and electrons were discovered, scientists sorted the elements by listing them in order of their atomic weights (today called relative atomic masses). Atomic weights could be measured, but nobody knew about atomic numbers.
The early periodic tables had two big problems:
- they were incomplete, because many elements had not yet been discovered and no spaces were left for them;
- if the strict order of atomic weights was followed, some elements were placed in inappropriate groups, next to elements with very different properties. One early table put the metals cobalt and nickel in the same group as the halogens.
Mendeleev's table
In 1869 Mendeleev published a table that put chemical properties first:
- he left gaps for elements that he thought had not been discovered, so that elements with similar properties stayed in the same group;
- in some places he changed the order based on atomic weights. He put tellurium (atomic weight 128) before iodine (127), so that iodine sat with chlorine and bromine, which it resembles;
- he used the elements around each gap to predict the properties of the missing elements.
Elements with the properties Mendeleev predicted were discovered and filled the gaps: gallium (1875), scandium (1879) and germanium (1886). Their properties were very close to his predictions. Some scientists had doubted the table because of its gaps and swaps, but successful predictions are strong evidence that a scientific idea is right, so the table became accepted.
His table had no noble gases. They are unreactive, colourless and odourless, so they were only discovered in the 1890s, when they were added as a new group.
How a gap can be predicted
Mendeleev left a gap between calcium (atomic weight 40.1) and titanium (47.9). Estimate the atomic weight of the missing element.
A simple estimate is the mean of its two neighbours:
\(\dfrac{40.1 + 47.9}{2} = 44.0\)
Mendeleev predicted 44 for this element. Scandium, discovered in 1879, has a relative atomic mass of 45.0, very close to the prediction. He made his predictions in a similar way, using the trends in the elements around each gap.
Atomic numbers and isotopes
After the proton was discovered, the elements were arranged in order of atomic number, the number of protons. Then every element falls into the group that matches its properties and no swaps are needed: tellurium (atomic number 52) does come before iodine (53), just as Mendeleev had decided.
Knowledge of isotopes made it possible to explain why the order based on atomic weights was not always correct. Relative atomic mass is an average that depends on the masses and abundances of an element's isotopes. Tellurium has a high proportion of heavy isotopes, with extra neutrons, so its relative atomic mass is larger than iodine's, even though it has fewer protons. The same thing happens with argon and potassium.
Remember
- Early tables: order of atomic weights; incomplete; some elements in the wrong groups.
- Mendeleev: left gaps, changed the order where needed, predicted missing elements.
- Predicted elements (gallium, scandium, germanium) were discovered and filled the gaps.
- Modern table: order of atomic number; isotopes explain the swaps.
Common mistakes
- Saying early scientists ordered elements by atomic number. Protons had not been discovered, so atomic numbers were not known.
- Saying Mendeleev used atomic number. He used atomic weight, but changed the order when properties did not fit.
- Saying the gaps were elements he had forgotten. They were spaces for elements that had not been discovered.
- Explaining the tellurium and iodine swap with "tellurium has more protons". It has fewer protons, but its isotopes have more neutrons on average.
- Saying Mendeleev was just lucky. His predictions came from the trends in each group, and several were confirmed.
Exam tip
In the 6-mark "describe the steps" question, keep the events in order and say why each step was an improvement. Use the key words: atomic weight, gaps, changed the order, predictions, discovered, atomic number, isotopes.