Question 1
1 markAli wants to compare the weather in his town in England with the weather in Madrid.
He works out
the mean daily temperature in his town in January,
the mean daily temperature in Madrid in July.
Explain why this is not a fair comparison.
Model answer
Ali is comparing a winter month in his town with a summer month in Madrid. Temperatures are usually much lower in January than in July, so the comparison is not like for like. He should compare the same month in both places.
Explanation
To compare two data sets fairly, the summary values must be worked out in the same way from comparable data. Using different months adds a seasonal difference that has nothing to do with the two places, so Ali should use the same month (or the whole year) for both.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for the temperatures are for different months (winter and summer), so he should compare the same month for both places oe
Accept 'January is winter and July is summer', 'it is not like for like'. Do not accept 'Madrid is hotter' or 'the samples are too small'.