Remind yourself of 'Winter Swans' by Owen Sheers in your AQA anthology.
Compare how poets present the strength of a relationship in 'Winter Swans' and in one other poem from 'Love and relationships'.
Model answer
'Winter Swans' and 'Letters from Yorkshire' both present relationships whose strength is quiet rather than showy, and both measure that strength by its ability to cross a distance in cold, wintry conditions. The distances, though, are very different. Dooley's speaker is separated by real miles from a man in Yorkshire, and the relationship holds through steady, regular contact. Sheers's couple walk side by side yet are emotionally far apart, and their relationship proves its strength by recovering from a crisis. One poem shows strength as endurance; the other as resilience.
Both poets distrust grand romantic statements. Dooley's speaker insists, "It's not romance", but "simply how things are", a flat, matter-of-fact line that locates the relationship's strength in its ordinariness. Sheers never names his couple's feelings at all. The speaker's response to the partner's comment about the swans is "I didn't reply", and when reconciliation comes it happens "somehow", without explanation. In both poems the bond is strong precisely because it does not need to be declared.
The distance each relationship must cross is central. Dooley sets two contrasting lives side by side: the man outdoors, digging and sowing in the cold, and the speaker indoors with a "heartful of headlines", feeding words onto a screen. The speaker's rhetorical question, asking whether a life of digging and sowing is more real, hints at envy or self-doubt, yet the difference does not weaken the bond. Sheers's distance is closer and harder to cross: the couple are together on the same path but "silent and apart". When the hands finally meet, Sheers says they have "swum the distance between us", a metaphor that makes a few inches of space feel as wide as the lake.
Birds act as signs of strength in both poems. Dooley's correspondent sees "the first lapwings return" and immediately comes indoors to write, his knuckles reddening in the warmth; the returning birds suggest seasonal reliability, and his instinct to share the moment shows how naturally the relationship sustains itself. Sheers's swans provide the model of lasting union, prompting the partner's remark, "They mate for life". The swans' constancy is a standard the couple must live up to; the lapwings simply prompt a habit of contact that is already secure.
The means of connection differ in an illuminating way. Dooley's relationship depends on words: the man's letters arrive "pouring air and light" into an envelope, a metaphor in which the outdoor world is posted to the speaker, and at night, sharing the same news broadcast in different houses, "our souls tap out messages" across "the icy miles". The verb suggests a steady, coded signal, like Morse, that cold and distance cannot interrupt. Sheers's couple reach each other without words: the hands are "folded, one over the other", and the simile of wings turns them into the pair the swans had shown. Both poems end with a connection that goes deeper than ordinary speech - souls signalling, hands folding - but one is spiritual and long-distance, the other physical and immediate.
Form reflects this. Both poems are written in free verse in three-line stanzas, an unsettled pattern for relationships under some strain. Dooley ends on a fifth tercet: the two remain physically apart, joined only in spirit. Sheers breaks his pattern with a final couplet, so the form itself becomes a pair at the moment of physical reunion. Context adds weight to Sheers's ending. 'Winter Swans' comes from Skirrid Hill (2005), a collection much concerned with separation and the end of relationships, so this couple's ability to recover stands out as a rare sign of strength.
In conclusion, both poets locate a relationship's strength in small, unglamorous things - a letter, a gesture - rather than in romance. Dooley's relationship is strong because it endures distance patiently, season after season; Sheers's is strong because it survives a storm and finds its balance again.