Remind yourself of 'The Emigrée' by Carol Rumens in your AQA anthology.
Compare how poets present longing for a place in 'The Emigrée' and in one other poem from 'Power and conflict'.
Model answer
'Exposure' and 'The Emigrée' both present people separated from a place they long for, and in both the longing is for warmth and light seen from a cold or hostile present. But the longing ends in opposite ways. Owen's soldiers return home only in a dream and find the doors shut against them, so they turn back to the front and to death. Rumens's speaker can never return, yet the city comes to the speaker. Owen's longing ends in sacrifice; Rumens's in possession and defiance.
Both longings begin in a hostile present. Owen's soldiers lie in trenches lashed by "merciless iced east winds that knive us", the invented verb 'knive' turning the weather into an attacking enemy. Rumens's speaker lives in exile and later faces hostile people who circle and accuse. Against these present dangers, both poets set a dream of sunlight. Owen's freezing men drift into half-sleep, "sun-dozed", among blossoms "where the blackbird fusses"; Rumens's speaker remembers a homeland "sunlight-clear", untouched by "that November". In both poems the longed-for place is defined by warmth and light because the present is cold and dark.
The imagined journeys home are very different. Owen's soldiers travel as ghosts: "Slowly our ghosts drag home". They glimpse the dying fires and hear crickets, while "the innocent mice rejoice: the house is theirs". Home has carried on without them, and the climax is brutal: "Shutters and doors, all closed: on us the doors are closed". The repetition of "closed" seals them out. Rumens's speaker states that there is "no way back at all", yet the conjunction 'but' turns at once: "my city comes to me" in "its own white plane". Owen's men go to the place they long for and are refused; Rumens's place travels to meet the one who longs for it.
Both poets admit that the place may no longer exist as imagined. Owen's soldiers wonder, "Is it that we are dying?", and their dream of home slides into ghostliness. Rumens's speaker concedes that the remembered country "may by now be a lie". Yet neither gives up the longing: Owen's men keep faith with the idea of home, and Rumens's speaker still cannot get its language off the tongue.
Strikingly, both end by protecting the place they long for. Owen's soldiers accept that they must stay out in the cold so that home can survive: "Since we believe not otherwise can kind fires burn", they "turn back to our dying". Their longing becomes sacrifice. Rumens's speaker protects the city too: when hostile voices surround the speaker, "My city hides behind me". The speaker shields the city not by dying but by remembering, and the final line turns the speaker's own shadow into "evidence of sunlight". Owen's soldiers face death for a home they may never see again; Rumens's speaker lives for a city that can never be revisited.
Form shapes the longing. Four of Owen's stanzas end with the refrain "But nothing happens", and his pararhymes, such as "silent" and "salient", sound almost right but never quite chime, like a longing that is never fulfilled. Ellipses trail away like exhausted thought. Rumens's refrain does the opposite: every stanza ends on "sunlight", so the longing is answered each time it is expressed.
Context deepens the comparison. Owen served as an officer on the Western Front and drew on the experience of winter in the trenches; he was killed in November 1918, a week before the Armistice, so his longing for home was never fulfilled. His soldiers' reasoning about "kind fires" echoes the Christian idea of sacrifice, though Owen questions it: "love of God seems dying". Rumens's speaker is a political exile from an unnamed homeland, cut off by war, tyranny and closed borders.
In conclusion, both poems present longing for a place as intense and sensory, centred on warmth and light, and both show that place slipping out of reach. Owen's soldiers find the doors of home closed and give their lives to keep its fires burning; Rumens's speaker, with no way back, receives the city as a visitor and guards it. One longing is refused; the other is answered in memory.
Explanation
Strong answers compare the longing itself - the warm, sunlit place imagined from a cold present, the imagined return, the doubt and the final protective act - rather than describing the two situations separately. Analysis of the closed doors in 'Exposure' against "my city comes to me", and of the two refrains, gives the comparison precision. Owen's context should explain the soldiers' sacrifice, not be added at the end.