Remind yourself of 'Letters from Yorkshire' by Maura Dooley in your AQA anthology.
Compare the ways poets present rural life in 'Letters from Yorkshire' and in one other poem from 'Love and relationships'.
Model answer
'Letters from Yorkshire' and 'The Farmer's Bride' both present rural life, but from opposite positions. Mew's farmer speaks from inside it: his work, his community and the seasons govern everything, including his marriage, and his monologue exposes the loneliness and cruelty that rural life can contain. Dooley's speaker looks at rural life from outside, through the letters of a man who lives it, and sees it with admiration, even envy, while refusing to romanticise it.
In both poems the farming year shapes time. Mew's farmer begins "Three Summers since I chose a maid", measuring his marriage in seasons, and explains that he married in haste because "more's to do / At harvest-time than bide and woo". Farm work comes first, even in courtship, and the bride is treated almost as another task to be completed. Dooley's man is first seen in February, digging and planting, and his life is one of watching the seasons turn. For both men the land sets the rhythm of life, but Dooley's man finds joy in it, noticing the first returning lapwings, while Mew's farmer has no time for feeling.
Both poets show that rural life is hard, but the hardship differs. Dooley's man endures physical labour, "breaking ice on a waterbutt" and clearing paths through snow, which the speaker lists plainly to avoid any idyllic picture. In Mew's poem the hardness is human. When the bride runs away, the farmer and his neighbours hunt her like an animal, chasing her "flying like a hare" before their lanterns, and the farmer "turned the key upon her, fast". Dooley's countryside is defined by weather and work; Mew's by the power of a community over a frightened individual.
Nature imagery reveals each speaker's attitude. Mew's farmer constantly compares his wife to animals: she is "Shy as a leveret", does the housework like a mouse, and is at ease only with birds and rabbits. The similes suggest tenderness and wild beauty, but also that he sees her as a creature to be caught and kept. Dooley's imagery is about sharing rather than possessing: the man sees "the first lapwings return" and writes at once, so wild creatures become news passed on to someone he cares about.
Both poets use colour against the cold. As winter closes in, Mew's farmer notes that "The berries redden up to Christmas-time", and the darkening season sharpens his loneliness as he longs for someone else in the house. Dooley's man comes indoors to write, and his knuckles have "reddened in the warmth", an image made joyful by the word "singing". In Mew's poem winter colour signals unfulfilled longing; in Dooley's it signals warmth and connection.
The greatest difference lies in communication. Mew's farmer admits, "I've hardly heard her speak at all": husband and wife share a house but no words, and their relationship is defined by silence and fear. Dooley's two people live far apart but stay in touch; the man sends news of his world, and in the end their souls are tapping out messages across the distance. Rural life isolates people who live together in Mew's poem, yet connects people who live apart in Dooley's.
Voice and form reinforce this. Mew writes a dramatic monologue in rural dialect - "When us was wed" - with irregular stanzas and insistent rhyme, so we hear the farmer's limited perspective and his growing desire, until the final line breaks into repetition: "her eyes, her hair, her hair!" Dooley's speaker uses plain, standard English in five calm, unrhymed tercets, the voice of someone reflecting rather than confessing. Mew's form traps us inside one man's mind; Dooley's opens out towards another person.
Context explains much of the contrast. Mew (1869-1928) wrote at a time when husbands held great power over their wives and a farmer's wife was expected to work in the home, and her poem exposes what that could mean for a young woman. Dooley, who worked for some years in Yorkshire before moving to London, presents rural life as something chosen and valued. Mew shows the countryside as a place where love fails for lack of understanding; Dooley shows it as a source of the fresh air and light that sustain a relationship across distance.