Remind yourself of 'Like an Heiress' by Grace Nichols in your AQA anthology.
Compare how poets present the responsibility of each generation in 'Like an Heiress' and in one other poem from 'Worlds and lives'.
Model answer
'Like an Heiress' and 'A Century Later' both ask what one generation owes the next. Dharker's title looks back a hundred years to the young soldiers of the First World War and forward to a new generation of schoolgirls who take responsibility for their own future. Nichols's speaker, an heiress to a damaged shore, recognises a shared responsibility for the planet but retreats into comfort. Dharker shows the young taking up a burden that others have failed to lift; Nichols, more uneasily, shows an adult generation that sees its duty but may not act on it.
Both poems are concerned with legacy. Nichols's opening simile, "Like an heiress", introduces the idea of inheritance, but what this generation is passing on is the list of tyres, bottles and cups heaped on the sand: the legacy of a throwaway culture. The ocean has "rightly tossed back" this waste, as if returning responsibility to those who created it. Dharker's legacy is violence. Her school-bell is a "call to battle" and every step to class a step into the firing-line, so the language of the trenches is passed on to girls who simply want an education. A century later, the young are still being sent to a front line, but this time for their right to learn.
The poems differ most in who takes responsibility. In Dharker's poem it is the young. The girl "takes the bullet in the head" and, after a stanza break, walks on, refusing to be stopped. She speaks back to the weapon - "Bullet, she says, you are stupid" - and her courage spreads: "the schoolgirls are standing up" to take their places on the front line. Nichols's speaker, by contrast, stands still and gazes, then heads for the "sanctuary" of her hotel to brood in "air-conditioned coolness". The irony is pointed: air-conditioning relieves heat while consuming energy, so her comfort may add to the problem. Some readers see Nichols turning a critical eye on her own generation.
Both poets make responsibility collective. Dharker's final image, "A murmur, a swarm", presents a movement growing from many small voices, "one by one". Nichols ends on the fate of "our" planet: the collective pronoun draws the reader into the responsibility, and "the quickening years" suggest there is little time left to accept it.
Ordinary life plays opposite roles. For Dharker, the girl has won "the right to be ordinary", to wear bangles, paint her nails and go to school; securing an ordinary life is the victory each generation must win for the next. For Nichols, ordinary life is part of the problem, since the rubbish on the beach is made of everyday objects. One poem fights for the ordinary; the other shows its cost.
Nature imagery points to the future in both. The bullet opens a path in the girl's mind to "an orchard / in full bloom" and a field full of poppies, images of growth and of remembered sacrifice, suggesting a future that is earned. Nichols's nature is a polluted shore under a burning sun, a future that is threatened.
Form supports these attitudes. Dharker's free verse moves from violence to vision to collective triumph, its enjambment across a stanza break enacting the girl's refusal to stop. Nichols's free-verse sonnet turns at once from delight to unease and ends without resolution, as if the responsibility is still waiting to be taken.
Context sharpens the comparison. Published in 2014, the centenary of the First World War, 'A Century Later' echoes Owen's 'Anthem for Doomed Youth' and responds to the shooting of Malala Yousafzai in 2012, when she was fifteen. 'Like an Heiress', from Nichols's 2020 sequence about a return to Guyana, belongs to an age of climate change, when the damage done by one generation falls on the next.
Dharker offers a hopeful vision of young people seizing responsibility; Nichols offers an uneasy recognition that her own generation must answer for the world it leaves behind.