Remind yourself of 'Kamikaze' by Beatrice Garland in your AQA anthology.
Compare how poets present the sea in 'Kamikaze' and in one other poem from 'Power and conflict'.
Model answer
The sea is central to both 'Storm on the Island' and 'Kamikaze', but it has opposite characters. Heaney's sea is a threat, deceptive and violent, seen close up from an island battered by a storm. Garland's sea is beautiful and life-giving, seen from high above and in memory, and it seems to offer the pilot a reason to live. Yet both seas are double-edged: Heaney's appears friendly before it turns savage, and Garland's beauty contains danger.
The poets view the sea from very different positions. Heaney's islanders face it at their own windows in a gale. Garland's pilot sees it from the cockpit: he "must have looked far down" at boats and fish, and the distance makes the scene calm, ordered and beautiful. Then memory carries him to the shore of his childhood. Heaney's sea comes too close; Garland's is seen from a height and then through the softening lens of memory.
Their imagery reflects this. Heaney gives the sea a deceptive face: an outsider might think it good company, but it is "Exploding comfortably" on the cliffs, an oxymoron that makes violence sound cosy, and then it spits "like a tame cat / Turned savage". The domestic image suggests a familiar creature betraying the people who trusted it. Garland's sea is full of colour and movement: a "green-blue translucent sea", with dark shoals of fish "flashing silver" as they sweep back and forth. Where Heaney's sea attacks, Garland's dances.
Both poets connect the sea with war, but in opposite directions. Heaney turns weather into war: the wind "strafes invisibly", like a fighter plane firing on the ground, and the islanders are under bombardment from the air. Garland, writing about a pilot on a wartime mission, turns the sea into a festival: the boats are "strung out like bunting", and the fish move like a huge waving flag. Heaney's peaceful island is under attack from nature; Garland's warrior is offered peace by it.
The sea's relationship with home also differs. Heaney's islanders build their homes against it, low and solid, and "just sit tight" while it rages. Garland's sea provides for home: the pilot remembers waiting with his brothers for their father's boat to come home safe, loaded with fish. The children's game, building cairns to test against "the turbulent inrush of breakers", shows them playing with the sea's danger rather than hiding from it.
Danger is present in both, but valued differently. Heaney's is feared and invisible, and the poem ends with "a huge nothing that we fear". Garland's is admired: the tuna, "the dark prince, muscular, dangerous", is a majestic creature, and the breakers are part of a childhood game. Heaney's islanders fear the sea's power; Garland's pilot loves it, and its beauty may be what turns him back.
Form mirrors each sea. Heaney's single block of blank verse is solid and enclosed, like a house braced against the weather, and the abrupt turn 'But no' reproduces the sudden change in the sea's mood. Garland's first sentence flows for thirty lines across five stanzas, its enjambment rolling one image into the next like waves.
Context adds depth. Heaney grew up on a farm in Northern Ireland, and 'Storm on the Island', from Death of a Naturalist (1966), describes island life in a storm; some readers see its war imagery as reflecting political tension, though this is an interpretation. Garland's pilot is a kamikaze of 1944-45, and the sea he flies over was meant to be the scene of his death, yet it reminds him of life.
In conclusion, both poems show the sea as a powerful force that shapes human lives. Heaney's sea is an enemy that turns from company to attacker, and his islanders can only endure it; Garland's is a giver of food, beauty and memory, and it calls a man back from death. One sea besieges a home; the other leads a man towards one.