Compare how poets present the hope of reunion with a loved one in 'Sonnet 29 - I think of thee!' and in one other poem from 'Love and relationships'.
[30 marks]
Sonnet 29 - 'I think of thee!'
I think of thee! - my thoughts do twine and bud
About thee, as wild vines, about a tree,
Put out broad leaves, and soon there's nought to see
Except the straggling green which hides the wood.
Yet, O my palm-tree, be it understood
I will not have my thoughts instead of thee
Who art dearer, better! Rather, instantly
Renew thy presence; as a strong tree should,
Rustle thy boughs and set thy trunk all bare,
And let these bands of greenery which insphere thee
Drop heavily down, - burst, shattered, everywhere!
Because, in this deep joy to see and hear thee
And breathe within thy shadow a new air,
I do not think of thee - I am too near thee.
Elizabeth Barrett Browning
Model answer
Both 'Sonnet 29' and 'Eden Rock' move towards a reunion with someone loved, and both end with a final line about thinking. But the people longed for, and the nature of the longing, are very different. Barrett Browning's speaker wants the presence of a living lover, here and now, and the sonnet ends with that desire fulfilled. Causley's speaker is drawn towards parents who appear as they were when young and who seem to wait beyond death, so the poem ends on the edge of a crossing that is both tender and unsettling.
Both speakers make the loved ones present through the mind, but they value imagination in opposite ways. Barrett Browning's speaker rejects it. Thoughts "twine and bud" round the lover until "the straggling green" hides the tree, and the speaker declares, "I will not have my thoughts instead of thee". Imagined presence is a barrier. Causley's speaker, by contrast, builds the parents lovingly out of precise memories: the father in "Genuine Irish Tweed" with his terrier, the mother pouring milk from an "H.P. sauce bottle", "The same three plates" and "tin cups painted blue". The homely details make the scene vivid and real, as if the speaker's desire to be with them can recreate them.
Time works differently in each poem. Barrett Browning's desire is urgent and present: "Rather, instantly / Renew thy presence", with a caesura that makes the speaker sound impatient. Causley's parents exist in a frozen past rendered in the present tense: "They are waiting for me". The father is "twenty-five" and the mother "twenty-three", probably younger than the speaker who now imagines them, and the dog is "Still two years old". The word "Still" suggests a moment held for ever. One speaker wants the future to arrive now; the other wants to return to a past that has been preserved.
Both poets associate the beloved with light and with something larger than ordinary life. Barrett Browning's speaker longs to "breathe within thy shadow a new air", where the lover's shade offers shelter and renewal. Causley's scene glows: the sky whitens "as if lit by three suns" and the mother's hair "takes on the light". The title's allusion to Eden and this unearthly brightness suggest a kind of paradise. Yet a boundary remains. The parents are on "the other bank" of a stream, and they "beckon" "Leisurely", calling out that "Crossing is not as hard" as the speaker might expect. Many readers see the stream as the line between life and death, so the desire to be with them carries a quiet sense of mortality.
The final lines make the comparison precise. Barrett Browning ends, "I do not think of thee - I am too near thee." Thought has been replaced by presence; the desire is satisfied. Causley ends with a single line set apart from the rest, in which the speaker admits "I had not thought" that it would be "like this". Here experience surpasses thought too, but the line is ambiguous: it could express wonder at how easy the reunion is, or a shiver of surprise at facing death. Isolated on the page, it leaves the speaker poised between the two banks.
Form reflects these differences. Barrett Browning's Petrarchan sonnet moves through its turn at "Yet" to a resolution. Causley's poem is built from calm, regular quatrains whose loose rhymes match the unhurried picnic, but it narrows to three lines and then to one, as if the speaker is stepping towards the edge.
Context adds depth to both. Barrett Browning wrote during a courtship carried on largely at a distance and against her father's wishes, so the desire to be with the beloved was real and urgent. Causley's father died in 1924, when Causley was seven, from the effects of the First World War, which may explain why the father is fixed for ever at twenty-five.
In conclusion, both poems show how powerfully people hope to be reunited with those they love. Barrett Browning's speaker finds that reunion in life and joy; Causley's finds it waiting beyond memory and perhaps beyond death.