Remind yourself of 'Thirteen' by Caleb Femi in your AQA anthology.
Compare how poets present fear in 'Thirteen' and in one other poem from 'Worlds and lives'.
Model answer
In both 'Thirteen' and 'Homing', fear grows from the way people in authority treat a young person's identity. In Berry's poem, the relative was made as a child to fear their own Black Country voice, and hid it for the rest of their life. In Femi's, a thirteen-year-old fears what police officers might do to him, because of how they see him. Berry presents fear as a long-lasting shame that is turned inwards; Femi presents it as immediate, physical terror. Berry's speaker finally overcomes the fear; Femi's boy is left inside it.
In both poems the fear is connected with school. Berry's relative was taught to be ashamed through "hours of elocution" and "the teacher's ruler across your legs", a punishment that turned the child's natural speech into something dangerous. Femi's boy remembers the second officer giving a talk at his primary school, and at the end he recalls his teacher's lesson about supernovas. In Berry's poem a teacher creates the fear; in Femi's, the memory of school offers a hope of safety that fails.
Both poets locate fear in the body, especially the mouth. Berry's relative kept the accent locked away "in a box beneath the bed", the lock "rusted shut" by years of suppression, so fear silenced the voice. Femi's boy feels fear settle on his mouth: it "condenses on your lips", cold and visible, as if stopping the words he has been trying to speak. Elsewhere his whole body is exposed. He is "cornered", and the officer sees him as "powerless - plump", soft prey for the two men who "cast lots for your organs".
The frightened person in each poem tries to make themselves acceptable to authority. Berry's relative hid the accent so thoroughly that the family heard it escape only now and then, in unguarded moments. Femi's boy smiles, showing "the warmth of your teeth", while silently hoping that the officer will remember him. The smile is a mask: it hides his fear behind the friendliness he thinks will keep him safe. Both strategies involve hiding or softening the self, and both reveal how fear changes behaviour.
The poems differ most in how fear ends. Berry's speaker, clearing the dead relative's house, wants only the box, "jemmied open" to release the lost words, and longs to "forge your voice" in the mouth and "shout it from the roofs". The fear that silenced one generation is defeated by the next. Femi's boy has no such release. The poem ends with the memory that supernovas are dying stars on the way to becoming "black holes", an image of hope collapsing.
Both poems are written in the second person, but the person addressed differs. Berry's speaker addresses a beloved relative, tenderly recalling their fear from the outside. Femi addresses the boy and, through him, the reader, so that we experience the fear from the inside. His future tense adds a further fear: that this will happen again, to this boy and to others like him, as a routine part of growing up.
Context shows that both fears grow from prejudice. Berry writes about the Black Country, where regional, working-class accents were long looked down on and people took elocution lessons to sound like speakers of Received Pronunciation. Femi grew up on the North Peckham estate; his poem never names race, but it is widely read as an account of racial profiling, and official figures show that Black people are stopped and searched at several times the rate of White people.
Ultimately, both poets show fear imposed on the young by those with authority over them. Berry suggests that such fear can be undone by love and pride; Femi shows a fear that is still happening, and that no single boy can undo.