How do writers present betrayal in 'Korea' and in one other story from Telling Tales?
Write about:
- examples of betrayal, or of characters who feel betrayed, in the two stories
- how the writers present betrayal.
[30 marks]
AO4
Model answer
John McGahern's 'Korea' and Graham Swift's 'Chemistry' are both told by grown men looking back at the moment in boyhood when a parent seemed to betray them. McGahern's narrator discovers that his father would profit from his death; Swift's narrator feels that his mother has abandoned him, his grandfather and his dead father for a new man. Yet neither story offers a simple picture of a wronged child. In both, the sons are also turning away from their parents' worlds, and the adult narrators' voices leave room for the reader to see betrayal from more than one side.
McGahern first builds the trust that will be broken. Father and son work together on the river in what is to be their last summer of fishing, and the father shares his memory of the execution he once witnessed. When the father begins to talk of America as the "land of opportunity", it sounds like generosity, a chance for the son to escape poverty. But the son is uneasy: the words seem borrowed, too grand for his father, and McGahern makes the reader share that unease.
The betrayal arrives through an overheard conversation. The son hears his father and Mr Farrell discussing Luke Moran, who was killed in Korea; his family got "ten thousand dollars", and "Every American soldier's life is insured". The son realises that if he went to America he could be conscripted, and that his father has weighed his son's life against money. McGahern does not describe a dramatic reaction; the son, who has overheard through the lavatory door while putting away the worms used for bait, closes it and stands in the darkness among the boxes of worms. The squalid setting expresses his disgust more powerfully than any outburst could.
McGahern complicates the betrayal. The father himself feels betrayed by the state: he "fought for this country", yet now the licence to fish is being taken away. His plan grows from bitterness and poverty, not simple greed. And even before the discovery, the son feels that he is "discarding his life" to take up his own. The story ends in a silence that neither will break, with the son watching his father as closely as if he too had to prepare himself to murder. Trust is not restored, but the reader understands how two lives have been pulled apart.
Swift's betrayal happens inside the home. After the deaths of the boy's father and grandmother, the family lives in a fragile balance, held together by Grandfather. When Ralph arrives, the mother gradually chooses him, and the boy experiences each step as treachery. Ralph even wears one of the dead father's sweaters, as if taking over his identity. When Ralph tells Grandfather to leave her alone, the old man's bitter reply - what does Ralph know about "being left alone"? - shows that he, too, feels deserted by the daughter he has supported. The boy's loyalty remains with Grandfather, whose loneliness, he feels, is written on the shed door in a form "only I could read".
The boy's response to betrayal is dangerous. He plans to throw acid in Ralph's face, meaning to "spoil his face" so that his mother will no longer want him. Then Grandfather kills himself, which the boy experiences as a further abandonment and as an act aimed at those who pushed him out. Afterwards the adults shut the boy out: the police, encouraged by his mother, do not question him, and his mother, he says, has spent years trying to explain or avoid explaining. Swift's adult narrator still sees his mother as the betrayer, but his account also lets the reader glimpse her guilt and confusion.
Both writers, then, present betrayal as the moment when a child sees a parent clearly for the first time. McGahern uses restraint, an overheard conversation and a final silence; Swift uses a child's intense, partial view, dialogue in the household quarrels and symbols such as the sunken launch. McGahern sets his story in 1950s Ireland, where poverty and emigration put families under strain; Swift sets his in an ordinary household changed by grief and remarriage. In both, the sense of betrayal shapes the narrator's whole life, which is why each tells the story so many years later.