How does Priestley present ideas about compassion in An Inspector Calls?
Write about:
- examples of characters showing compassion, or failing to show it
- how Priestley presents ideas about compassion.
[30 marks]
AO4
Model answer
Compassion - the ability to feel another person's suffering and act to relieve it - is the quality most missing from the Birling household. Priestley presents it through absence and through imitation: the Birlings offer charity without feeling, kindness with conditions, and sympathy that disappears as soon as it is no longer needed. Against them he sets the Inspector and, most movingly, Eva herself. The play argues that compassion cannot be left to the moods of comfortable individuals; it must become the basis of how society is organised.
Mrs Birling is the play's sharpest example of charity without compassion. She sits on a committee devoted to "deserving cases", a phrase that reveals her belief that help must be earned by the right kind of person. When Eva, pregnant and desperate, appeals for help, Mrs Birling is offended that the girl called herself Mrs Birling, admits that this "prejudiced me against her case", and later sneers at her "ridiculous airs". The Inspector's reply is blunt: Eva came to her at a time when no woman "could have needed it more". Priestley's irony is clear. The woman whose public role is charity is the least charitable person in the play, because she judges before she feels.
Mr Birling shows a different failure: he cannot imagine anyone's suffering but his own. When the Inspector's questions spoil the evening, Birling complains that they were having "a nice little family celebration". The Inspector turns his words back on him, saying he had been thinking the same thing while looking at what was left of Eva - a promising life, and "a nasty mess" someone had made of it. The juxtaposition of a ruined dinner party and a ruined life exposes how small Birling's world of feeling is.
Gerald's case is more complicated, because he did show kindness. He rescued Daisy Renton from Alderman Meggarty, gave her somewhere to live and some money. Yet Priestley makes the audience question his motives. Gerald enjoyed being the object of her gratitude, and when the affair no longer suited him he ended it. His compassion was real but conditional, and it lasted only as long as it gave him pleasure.
The younger Birlings show that compassion can be learned. Sheila's first reaction to the news of Eva's death is distress at the thought of a girl "destroying herself so horribly". This contrasts painfully with what she did at Milwards, when jealousy and temper overcame any thought of the shop girl's livelihood, and her shame shows her moving from selfishness to sympathy. Eric, too, sympathises with the strikers early on and later feels Eva's death as a personal loss, although his attempt to help her with stolen money shows how confused his kindness was.
The most compassionate character never appears. Eva refused money she believed was stolen, protected Eric by hiding the identity of her child's father, and, according to Gerald, "didn't blame me at all" when he left her. Priestley gives the girl the family despises the very quality they lack. The Inspector, who speaks for her, completes the picture: his graphic descriptions of her death force the family to feel what they would rather ignore, and his final speech widens their duty to the millions of "Eva Smiths and John Smiths". If we are "members of one body", then compassion is not an optional virtue but the recognition that another person's suffering is our own.
This argument belongs to Priestley's moment. In 1912 the poor depended heavily on private charity, often run by people like Mrs Birling who decided who was deserving. During the Second World War, Priestley's radio broadcasts called for a fairer society after the war, and the Beveridge Report of 1942 proposed a welfare state that would protect everyone from want and illness. By the time the play reached London in 1946, British audiences were watching help become a right guaranteed by the state rather than a favour granted by the comfortable.
In conclusion, Priestley presents compassion as the missing foundation of the Birlings' world. Through Mrs Birling's judgemental charity, Birling's self-pity and Gerald's conditional kindness, he exposes its counterfeits, while Eva, the Inspector and the changing Sheila and Eric show what real compassion looks like. The play urges its audience to build that compassion into society itself.