'The care system fails Leon.'
How far do you agree with this view of My Name is Leon?
Write about:
- what happens to Leon in the care system and how the adults in it treat him
- how far de Waal presents the care system as failing Leon.
[30 marks]
AO4
Model answer
De Waal knew the care system from the inside: her mother was a foster carer, and she later advised social services and sat on adoption panels. She has said that she wanted to write about 'a care system that didn't care very much', yet also that it is 'populated by committed social workers and foster carers'. My Name is Leon reflects both views. I largely agree that the system fails Leon, especially in separating him from Jake, but de Waal also shows individuals within it who rescue him.
The system's first failure is that it arrives so late. Leon cares for a baby alone for some time, missing school, while his mother lies in bed. No one intervenes until Tina, desperate, calls an ambulance and social services. The Guardian's reviewer noted that moments like this reveal 'how much child protection has moved on' since the early 1980s. By the time help comes, Leon has already learned to hide trouble from adults, a habit that shapes the rest of the novel.
The greatest failure is the separation of the brothers. The social workers decide that Jake, a white baby, will be adopted, while Leon, older and mixed race, will not. De Waal shows the decision through Leon's bewildered eyes, but gives Maureen the words to judge it: "Jake's got a chance, you mean", she says bitterly, and "You've split them up", which "in my books" is "a sin". Her blunt, colloquial anger contrasts with the careful language of the professionals and exposes what their politeness hides. De Waal has said that brothers like Leon and Jake would very likely still be split up today, and the novel makes us feel the cost of such decisions for the child left behind.
The system also fails to speak honestly to Leon. Decisions are made about him in lowered voices, so he learns the truth by eavesdropping or snooping. When he reads Carol's file in the social worker's bag, he discovers that she has missed visits and is judged to have a "high level of self-interest" - information no adult has shared with him. Later an Independent Reviewing Officer tells him that Jake's adoption is final and that he cannot live with his brother. Leon's response, wrecking Sylvia's bathroom, shows the gap between the system's procedures and a child's grief. The close third-person narration keeps us inside Leon's confusion, so we experience the system as he does: powerful, distant and hard to understand.
There are other failures, too. Leon moves from his home to Maureen's and then to Sylvia's, losing his toys and his familiar world along the way. His stealing, lying and anger grow as he is moved and left uninformed. The system meets his physical needs but, for much of the novel, seems to have no plan for his feelings.
However, de Waal does not present the care system as wholly bad. It places Leon with Maureen, whose warmth, food and honesty give him the security he never had with Carol. The social worker Leon calls the Zebra, because of her black-and-white hair, brings him a bike, which gives him freedom and leads him to the allotments, to Tufty and to Mr Devlin. Sylvia, who takes him in when Maureen falls ill, keeps him within a family rather than among strangers. These are people working in or alongside the system who go beyond its routines.
The ending makes this balance clearer. After Carol tells Leon that she cannot look after him, Maureen reveals that she has arranged for him to stay with her permanently. The system that separated Leon from Jake also, through Maureen, gives him a lasting home. The final image of Leon running towards her suggests that care can work when it is built on love rather than on procedures alone.
In conclusion, I agree that the care system fails Leon in important ways: it reacts too late, splits him from his brother partly because of race, and leaves him uninformed and powerless. But de Waal is fair to the individuals in it. Maureen, the Zebra and Sylvia show that the system's failures can be softened by people who care, and that what Leon needs is not a perfect institution but adults who are honest with him and refuse to give up on him.