'Harri is still an innocent child when he dies.'
How far do you agree with this view of Pigeon English?
Write about:
- what Harri says, does and learns during the novel
- how far Kelman presents Harri as still innocent at the end.
[30 marks]
AO4
Model answer
I largely agree with this view, but with an important qualification. Kelman shows Harri's innocence being damaged throughout the novel - by violence, temptation and abuse - yet at its core it survives. Harri dies knowing far more than he did in March, but he has not become corrupt. That is what makes his death so painful: the estate kills a child who is still, in the ways that matter most, a child.
Harri's innocence is clearest in his misreadings of the adult world. He believes that "Mamma likes it best" when a child dies on the news, because that is when she prays hardest; the reader sees her fear where he sees joy. He wonders who would "chook a boy" just to get his food from Chicken Joe's, not grasping that the murder had nothing to do with chicken. His habit of backing up rumours with "everybody agrees" shows a boy who still trusts what he is told. Kelman uses this naive first-person voice to create constant dramatic irony: we understand the danger that Harri cannot.
However, Kelman also shows violence seeping into Harri. In the opening he notes that the blood was "darker than you thought", and the image haunts him. In art he tries again and again to paint the right red, and his frustration suggests a trauma he cannot name. He even jabs himself with a fork to see what being stabbed might feel like. This curiosity is childish, but its object is death, and Kelman shows how quickly an environment can shape a child's imagination.
Harri is also capable of cruelty. When a tree comes down at school and a younger boy suggests that a cat killed the birds, Harri pushes him over and admits he "even wanted him to cry". After the Dell Farm Crew make Dean pay to pass them, Harri and Dean charge smaller children to use an old mattress. These moments suggest that he is learning the estate's habits of power, passing intimidation down the line.
The greatest test of his innocence is the gang. Harri wants to join so that "Vilis couldn't abuse me", and he talks himself into believing that a gang can be "for good things". His second test is to take part in mugging Mr Frimpong, an old man from his own church. Yet at the decisive moment he runs past, and afterwards throws away the coat he was wearing in shame. From then on he draws his pretend scars without stitches, as if a wound that will not heal now belongs to him. His guilt is itself a sign that his conscience is intact.
Other people also take innocence from him. Miquita's sexual assault in July is a violation that leaves him confused and disgusted, and Kelman presents it as something done to him, not something he chose. It shows how the adult world forces its way into childhood on the estate, even inside the family's flat.
Nevertheless, the final chapter restores Harri's innocence powerfully. On the last day of term he kisses Poppy, runs home through the rain loving everything he passes, and is happier than at any point in the novel. Even when stabbed, his last wish is for the pigeon to tell Agnes his funny story from the plane. Earlier he offered God his own life in exchange for his baby sister's - an act of pure, if naive, love. Kelman said in an interview that he wanted to see how a child dropped into a dark situation might 'retain his own morality', and Harri does.
Context sharpens the point. Kelman wrote the novel in response to the killing of ten-year-old Damilola Taylor in 2000, whom he has described as 'a genuinely good kid'. Harri, like Damilola, is attacked on his way home. By keeping Harri good to the end, Kelman resists any suggestion that the victims of knife crime must somehow have been involved in it.
So I agree that Harri is still innocent when he dies, though not untouched. He has seen blood, felt temptation and suffered abuse, and he has sometimes been cruel himself. But his conscience, his kindness and his joy survive. Kelman's tragedy is not that Harri becomes corrupt, but that his innocence is no protection at all.
Explanation
Strong answers take a clear position on the view and test it against the whole novel, weighing evidence of damaged innocence (the blood, cruelty to smaller children, the gang's pull, the mugging, Miquita's assault) against Harri's surviving conscience and joy in the final chapter. They analyse Kelman's methods - the naive narrator, dramatic irony, motifs of blood and scars, and the ending's structure - and use context such as Kelman's stated aims and the Damilola Taylor case. Weaker answers list innocent moments without considering the counter-argument.