Remind yourself of 'Climbing My Grandfather' by Andrew Waterhouse in your AQA anthology.
Compare how poets present closeness to someone you love in 'Climbing My Grandfather' and in one other poem from 'Love and relationships'.
Model answer
Both 'Climbing My Grandfather' and 'Sonnet 29 - I think of thee!' present closeness to a loved one through the image of a large, sheltering natural form. Barrett Browning's speaker addresses the beloved as a palm-tree; Waterhouse's grandchild climbs a grandfather as if he were a mountain. In both poems to be close is to be in that figure's shelter. But the kinds of closeness differ. Barrett Browning's is romantic and longed for, and its climax is a nearness so complete that thought disappears; Waterhouse's is the closeness of family, achieved through physical exploration, and its climax is a new kind of knowledge.
Both loved ones are seen as tall and strong. Barrett Browning's speaker calls the beloved "O my palm-tree" and asks the tree to act "as a strong tree should", an image of height, strength and nobility. Waterhouse's grandfather is a whole landscape, with a summit to be reached. In both poems the speaker looks up to the loved one, literally and figuratively.
The obstacles to closeness are different. In 'Sonnet 29' the problem is the speaker's own imagination: thoughts "twine and bud / About thee, as wild vines", spreading until they hide the real person. The speaker demands, "Renew thy presence", wanting the beloved rather than mere thoughts. Waterhouse's speaker faces no such barrier, deciding to climb "without a rope or net", so there is nothing between climber and grandfather. Contact is immediate and physical, from "pushing into the weave" of his trousers onwards.
The most striking parallel is the idea of shelter. Barrett Browning's speaker longs to "breathe within thy shadow a new air", and Waterhouse's climber rests "in the shade" at the grandfather's shoulder. In both, closeness means being protected by the loved one's presence, a shade that brings rest and renewal. Yet Barrett Browning's shadow is imagined and desired, while Waterhouse's shade is experienced, part of a journey that is happening now.
Both poets make closeness a matter of the senses. Barrett Browning finds "deep joy to see and hear thee" and to breathe in the beloved's presence. Waterhouse uses an even wider range: the climber stares "into his brown eyes", drinks "among teeth" at the smiling mouth and, at the summit, lies "feeling his heat". Physical closeness in Waterhouse's poem is almost total, from the shoes to the hair.
The endings show what closeness achieves. Barrett Browning's speaker concludes with a paradox: "I do not think of thee - I am too near thee." Closeness is so complete that thought becomes unnecessary. Waterhouse's speaker ends with knowledge rather than its absence: lying at the top, the climber is "knowing" the slow pulse of "his good heart". For Barrett Browning, nearness silences the mind; for Waterhouse, it allows the speaker truly to understand the grandfather.
Form reflects each experience. 'Sonnet 29' is a Petrarchan sonnet full of exclamations and dashes, a traditional love form strained by urgent feeling. 'Climbing My Grandfather' is a single unbroken stanza in the present tense, so the closeness grows continuously, hold by hold. Context adds depth. Barrett Browning wrote the sonnets around 1845-46 during her courtship with Robert Browning, which had to be kept secret from her father, so the longing for presence had real obstacles; they were published in 1850 as Sonnets from the Portuguese. Waterhouse, who often wrote about the natural world, imagines the grandfather as a landscape, so that closeness to him feels like closeness to the earth itself.
In conclusion, both poets present closeness as shelter within a strong, natural presence. Barrett Browning's speaker longs for it and, once near, needs no more thought; Waterhouse's grandchild earns it through effort and, once there, finally knows the good heart of the person they love.