Remind yourself of 'Bayonet Charge' by Ted Hughes in your AQA anthology.
Compare how poets present a soldier's change of heart in 'Bayonet Charge' and in one other poem from 'Power and conflict'.
Model answer
Both 'Bayonet Charge' and 'Kamikaze' show a soldier whose commitment to a patriotic mission suddenly changes, but the changes happen in very different ways. Hughes's soldier undergoes a change of heart in a few seconds of terror: his patriotic ideals fall away and he is driven forward by fear alone. Garland's pilot changes his mind in the calm of the sky, moved by the beauty of the sea and by memories of his childhood, and he turns back. Hughes presents a change forced by panic; Garland presents a quiet, human decision with devastating consequences.
Both poems begin with a soldier shaped by patriotic duty. Hughes's soldier once felt "The patriotic tear" brim in his eye, though by the poem's opening it has become sweat "like molten iron", hot and heavy. Garland's pilot sets out ceremonially, with "a samurai sword" and a head "full of powerful incantations", carrying enough fuel for a one-way "journey into history". The list of ritual objects suggests a man filled with his nation's ideas of honour. In both poems patriotism is presented as something put into the soldier - a feeling he once had, words chanted into a shaven head - rather than something he has chosen.
In both poems the natural world is bound up with the change. In 'Bayonet Charge' the decisive moment comes with a "yellow hare" thrown up by the gunfire, crawling in agony with its mouth "Open silent". The suffering animal mirrors the soldier's terror, and immediately afterwards his ideals are gone. In 'Kamikaze' the change is prompted by beauty: the daughter imagines her father looking down at the "little fishing boats" and the shoals of fish flashing silver beneath them, which bring back memories of his brothers waiting on the shore for their father's boat. Hughes's nature shows the soldier the horror of war; Garland's shows the pilot the value of life.
The change itself is presented very differently. Hughes's soldier does not decide anything. "King, honour, human dignity, etcetera" are "Dropped like luxuries" in a yelling alarm, as if they slip from his grasp, and the dismissive final word shows how little they now mean. He does not turn back but plunges on towards the hedge. Garland never shows the moment of decision directly; it is guessed at by the daughter - "he must have looked" - and the long, flowing sentences full of sea imagery suggest a gradual, almost dreamlike change of mind. Hughes's soldier changes inside while his body keeps charging; Garland's pilot physically turns his plane round.
The consequences differ sharply. We never learn what happens to Hughes's soldier: the poem ends in mid-charge, with terror his only motive. Garland follows her pilot home, where his change of heart costs him everything: his wife "never spoke again" in his presence, and the neighbours and finally his own children treat him as if he no longer exists. Ironically, the decision that saved his life ended it socially, and the last line imagines him wondering which had been "the better way to die".
Form and voice shape our response. Hughes's third-person narrator stays close to the soldier's body, and the free verse, enjambment and dashes make his change of heart feel involuntary, physical and immediate. Garland's narrative is distant and layered - the daughter's account reported by another voice - so the pilot's change of heart remains mysterious, and our sympathy extends to the family as much as to him.
Context explains why each change matters. Hughes's poem, from The Hawk in the Rain (1957), is usually read as set in the First World War; written by a poet whose father survived Gallipoli, it looks back on that war's patriotic slogans with hindsight, and the soldier's abandoned ideals reflect their hollowness. Garland's poem is set in the Second World War, when Japanese kamikaze pilots were expected to die on their missions and a pilot who returned brought shame on his family; turning back was seen as a betrayal of honour.
Both poets therefore present a change of heart that exposes the emptiness of patriotic duty, but they differ in its cause and its cost. Hughes's soldier is changed by terror and keeps running; Garland's pilot is changed by love of life and turns back, only to find that his community cannot forgive him.