Compare how poets present things that are shut away in 'In a London Drawingroom' and in one other poem from 'Worlds and lives'.
[30 marks]
In a London Drawingroom
The sky is cloudy, yellowed by the smoke.
For view there are the houses opposite
Cutting the sky with one long line of wall
Like solid fog: far as the eye can stretch
Monotony of surface & of form
Without a break to hang a guess upon.
No bird can make a shadow as it flies,
For all is shadow, as in ways o'erhung
By thickest canvass, where the golden rays
Are clothed in hemp. No figure lingering
Pauses to feed the hunger of the eye
Or rest a little on the lap of life.
All hurry on & look upon the ground,
Or glance unmarking at the passers by
The wheels are hurrying too, cabs, carriages
All closed, in multiplied identity.
The world seems one huge prison-house & court
Where men are punished at the slightest cost,
With lowest rate of colour, warmth & joy.
George Eliot
Model answer
Both 'In a London Drawingroom' and 'pot' present things that are shut away, and both link enclosure with power and injustice. Eliot's poem shuts away the sky, the sunlight and finally a whole population, which she calls "one huge prison-house". Khan's poem is addressed to a single object, a pot shut behind museum glass and cut off from the people who made and used it. The crucial difference is that Khan's speaker wants to break the glass, while Eliot's poem allows no escape.
The poets show different kinds of enclosure. In Eliot's London nature itself is shut out: the houses are "Cutting the sky with one long line of wall", there is no "break" in their monotony, and the sun's "golden rays / Are clothed in hemp", as if light were wrapped in a sack. Even people are enclosed: the cabs and carriages are "All closed, in multiplied identity". Khan's pot is a single precious object behind glass, and the poem opens with the official reasons for keeping it there: it is large and "so fragile you might break", so "you shouldn't really be moved". These excuses, reported from an anonymous group of authorities, sound like care but work as control.
Both poems hint at why things are shut away, and in both the reasons involve money and power. Eliot's final lines speak of a world where "men are punished at the slightest cost", and the language of "cost" and "rate" suggests a society run as cheaply as possible. Khan's speaker asks how the pot reached England, and each possibility is introduced by "did they say": was it bought in "a looters' deal", or simply lost, since "finders are keepers"? The repetition creates a disbelieving tone, as if the speaker hears through each polite story to the taking underneath.
The things that are shut away are also emptied of life. Khan reminds us that the pot once had a life of use and care: someone shaped it, washed it, used it and "loved you pot". In the case it does none of these things; it is an "empty pot". Eliot's people are similarly emptied, denied any rest on "the lap of life" and living with the "lowest rate of colour, warmth & joy". In both poems, enclosure means coldness and emptiness, while freedom means warmth: Khan imagines hot sun on the pot's surface and "warm grain poured inside" it, exactly the warmth that Eliot's city lacks.
The speakers respond differently. Khan's speaker is passionate and personal: "if I could shatter this glass" is a sudden flash of anger, followed by a vow to carry the pot home in person, which shows a longing for justice. The speaker also identifies with the pot, recalling being told "you're not really one of us", so the shut-away object becomes a symbol for people separated from their roots. Eliot's observer is impersonal and never says "I"; from inside a drawing room, the poem records the prison without trying to open it.
Form makes the enclosures visible. Eliot's poem is one closed block of nineteen lines of blank verse with no stanza breaks, as solid as the wall it describes. Khan's poem is full of white space, short lines and single words, so the form itself seems open and broken, like glass that has been shattered. Both endings, however, are silent. Khan's speaker calls "growl if you hear me", and the poem ends with the single word "pot?", left without an answer. Eliot ends with an end-stopped verdict and no reply.
Context deepens both poems. Eliot wrote in 1865, in the age of the British Empire, during which many objects like Khan's pot were brought to Britain. Khan, a British Asian poet based in Manchester, wrote in response to a museum object, and her poem joins modern debates about whether objects taken during the Empire should be returned, as well as the experience of people living in diaspora.
Both poets therefore see enclosure as a sign of injustice. Eliot shows a whole society locked in; Khan focuses on one object and imagines, with anger and tenderness, setting it free.