Remind yourself of 'Shall earth no more inspire thee' by Emily Brontë in your AQA anthology.
Compare how poets present speakers who reach out to others in 'Shall earth no more inspire thee' and in one other poem from 'Worlds and lives'.
Model answer
Both 'Shall earth no more inspire thee' and James Berry's 'On an Afternoon Train from Purley to Victoria, 1955' are built around someone reaching out to another person. In Brontë's poem the speaker, usually read as nature, reaches out to a withdrawn dreamer with questions, memories and pleas, and receives no reply. In Berry's poem a Quaker woman reaches out to the speaker, a Jamaican man, on a London train, and he reaches back: a real dialogue, warm but marked by misunderstanding. Brontë's outreach rests on intimate knowledge; Berry's woman knows almost nothing about the man she speaks to. Yet in both poems sincerity is offered and met with reserve.
Both poems open with an unsettling approach. Brontë's speaker begins with a reproachful question, "Shall earth no more inspire thee", as if confronting a friend who has drifted away. Berry's woman begins simply - "Hello, she said" - but she "startled me": the speaker is unused to friendliness from strangers. Each outreach disturbs the other person's solitude.
The two speakers who reach out differ in what they know. Brontë's nature claims complete knowledge: "I know my mighty sway", it says, recalling the dreamer's past devotion "In fond idolatry" and claiming to have watched them every hour. Its outreach is confident because it is intimate. Berry's woman has good intentions - she was moved "for racial brotherhood" to "speak a poem loudly" - but her knowledge is limited. When she learns he is from Jamaica, she asks which part of Africa it is in, and imagines that no one would leave such a sunny country. Her outreach is sincere but clumsy, shaped by assumptions she does not notice.
Both poems link reaching out with inspiration. Brontë's speaker wants to re-inspire a person whose "passion may not fire thee"; the whole poem is an attempt to rekindle a lost feeling. Berry's woman acts on inspiration: she was moved in silence, as Quakers are, and her poem was "One the moment inspired". Her inspiration leads her to speak to a stranger, as nature's longing leads it to speak to the dreamer.
The responses differ. Brontë's dreamer is silent throughout; the speaker's pleas - "Come back and dwell with me" - are never answered. Berry's speaker responds, cautiously at first and then with curiosity, asking "what poem came on like that?" When she reveals her ignorance, he answers with gentle irony, pairing Ireland and Lapland, correcting her without hostility. Berry's poem shows reaching out as a two-way exchange, with all the awkwardness that brings.
Each poem ends with an image of connection. Brontë's speaker offers a home, "Return and dwell with me", and a final gesture of touch, "let my winds caress thee", but the offer hangs in the air. Berry's poem ends "So sincere she was beautiful", as people sat down "around us". The pronoun joins the two travellers, though it also marks them off from everyone else. Brontë's outreach waits for an answer; Berry's has created a fragile bond.
Form shapes these relationships. Brontë's dramatic monologue gives the outreach to one voice only, in regular quatrains that sound patient and persuasive. Berry's free verse presents dialogue without speech marks, so the two voices run together, and its short stanzas follow the conversation from greeting to reflection.
Context adds depth. Charlotte Brontë introduced the poem as the spirit of a solitary place recalling its 'wandering and wayward votary', so the outreach is that of a landscape to the person who loves it. Berry, born in Jamaica, had settled in London in the 1940s, and in 1955 Caribbean migrants often met ignorance as well as kindness; the woman's Quaker faith, centred on equality, explains her warmth, while her questions reveal how little many British people knew of the Caribbean.
Both poems, then, show that reaching out is an act of hope. Brontë's nature reaches towards someone who once loved it and waits; Berry's stranger reaches across differences she does not fully understand, and, despite her mistakes, something real passes between them.