Remind yourself of 'A Portable Paradise' by Roger Robinson in your AQA anthology.
Compare how poets present inner strength in 'A Portable Paradise' and in one other poem from 'Worlds and lives'.
Model answer
'A Portable Paradise' and 'A Century Later' both show people finding strength inside themselves, and both locate it in something that cannot be destroyed or stolen: Robinson's hidden paradise, and the mind of Dharker's schoolgirl and the books she defends. But the kinds of strength differ. Dharker's is public, defiant and shared, rising out of a moment of extreme violence; Robinson's is private, quiet and restorative, a way of surviving ordinary hardship. One poem is a battle cry, the other a lullaby, yet both celebrate resilience.
The threats are on very different scales. Dharker's poem opens with war imagery transferred to a school: the school-bell is a "call to battle" and every step to class is a step into the firing-line. The girl's vulnerability is stressed through "cheek still rounded from being fifteen", so the attack on her is an attack on childhood itself. Robinson's threats are everyday ones, the moments when life presses hard and stresses become "sustained and daily". Yet both poets suggest that endurance is needed in each case, whether against a bullet or against grinding routine.
The most striking parallel is that both find strength in an inner landscape of nature. In Dharker's poem, the bullet that the girl takes in the head is transformed: the missile cuts "a pathway in her mind" that leads to "an orchard / in full bloom" and a field humming under the sun. At the moment of greatest violence, her mind opens onto a paradise of growth. Robinson's speaker, at the moment of greatest stress, empties a remembered paradise onto a desk: "white sands, green hills" and fresh fish. In both poems, the mind holds a fertile, sunlit place that violence or hardship cannot reach.
Both poets also present strength as something that cannot be taken away. Dharker's girl "walks on", and the enjambment that carries the line across a stanza break makes her survival a surprise, as if nothing can stop her. She then speaks back: "Bullet, she says, you are stupid." Addressing the bullet directly turns the weapon into a foolish object and gives the girl the last word. Her defiance widens into a belief that "You cannot kill a book": ideas outlive violence. Robinson's paradise survives for a different reason. It is hidden, so "they can't steal it". Dharker's strength is open and confrontational; Robinson's depends on secrecy.
Both poems find heroism in ordinary life. The girl has won "the right to be ordinary", to wear bangles and paint her nails and go to school, and the commonplace list makes her victory moving. Robinson's speaker wins something equally ordinary: the chance to sleep, comforted by a lamp shining "like the fresh hope / of morning". Inner strength in both poems is less about grand gestures than about being able to carry on living.
Where strength leads differs. Dharker ends collectively: "A murmur, a swarm", and one by one "the schoolgirls are standing up" to take their places on the front line. The single girl's courage becomes a movement. Robinson's strength is also shared, but quietly: it passes from grandmother to speaker and, through the second person, to the reader. Dharker's poem spreads strength like a protest; Robinson's hands it down like a family secret.
Form supports these differences. Dharker's free verse shifts between short, blunt statements and longer flowing lines, matching the move from violence to vision to triumph. Robinson's single stanza of calm, conversational free verse never raises its voice, suited to strength that works in private.
Context explains the urgency of Dharker's poem. It responds to the shooting of Malala Yousafzai, who was attacked in 2012 at the age of fifteen for speaking up for girls' education and later received the Nobel Peace Prize, though the girl can stand for any girl denied schooling. Published in 2014, the centenary of the First World War, it echoes Owen's 'Anthem for Doomed Youth'. Robinson's poem grows from a grandmother's advice and, many readers feel, from his memories of Trinidad.
Together the poems suggest that inner strength takes many forms: Dharker's girl shows it by standing up in public, Robinson's speaker by holding on in private.