Remind yourself of 'Poppies' by Jane Weir in your AQA anthology.
Compare the ways poets present experiences of waiting in 'Poppies' and in one other poem from 'Power and conflict'.
Model answer
Both 'Poppies' and 'Exposure' are poems of waiting, in which people endure an uncertainty they cannot end. Owen's soldiers wait through freezing nights in the trenches for an attack that never comes; Weir's parent waits at home, and then at a war memorial, for some sign of a child who has gone. Owen presents waiting as a shared, physical suffering that slowly kills; Weir presents it as a private, emotional suffering felt in the body. Neither poem allows the waiting to end.
Owen builds waiting into the structure of his poem. Four of its eight stanzas end with the half-line "But nothing happens", a refrain that makes the reader live through the same anticlimax again and again, while the questions - "What are we doing here?" - show the men's bewilderment. Weir's poem has no refrain, but it unfolds as a series of waiting moments: it begins "Three days before Armistice Sunday", moves through the parting, and then, "Later", follows the speaker's walk. Both structures stretch time, so that the reader feels its slowness.
In both poems waiting means listening. Owen's sentries are "Worried by silence" and "whisper, curious, nervous", straining for any sound, while distant guns rumble "Like a dull rumour of some other war". Weir's poem ends with the parent listening, "hoping to hear" the child. The soldiers listen for danger and the parent for a beloved voice, but both are listening into emptiness.
Weather turns waiting into suffering. Owen's soldiers are attacked by "merciless iced east winds that knive us", and the title points to death from exposure to cold. Weir's speaker goes out "hat-less", without coat, scarf or gloves - a voluntary exposure, as if bodily comfort no longer matters. The wind runs through both poems: in Owen it is cruel and indifferent, "the wind's nonchalance"; in Weir it is the faint carrier of a voice "catching on the wind". Nature offers neither group any comfort.
Both poems connect waiting with home, in a striking reversal. Owen's soldiers drift into dreams of home, but find that "on us the doors are closed", and so "We turn back to our dying": home has no place for them. Weir's speaker, at home, "threw" open the front door so that the child could leave. In Owen, the men waiting in the trenches are shut out of home; in Weir, the person waiting at home has opened the door and lost the one inside.
The poets also locate waiting in the body differently. Owen's begins with "Our brains ache" and ends with frost "Shrivelling many hands": waiting is a slow physical destruction that leaves the men numb and drowsy. Weir's waiting is restless; the stomach is busy "making tucks, darts, pleats", folding itself like fabric, and the speaker cannot stay still at home. One kind of waiting freezes people in place; the other drives the speaker out to walk.
Form reinforces these differences. Owen's long, slow lines and pararhymes, such as "knive us" and "nervous", never quite resolve, like the waiting itself, and the collective "we" makes the suffering shared. Weir's free verse and enjambment follow one person's thoughts, and the move into the present tense at the end leaves the speaker still waiting as the poem closes.
Context gives the comparison special poignancy. Owen wrote from his own experience of the trenches in winter, and he was killed on 4 November 1918, a week before the Armistice, so he never saw the end of the war he describes. Weir's poem opens three days before Armistice Sunday, the day that remembers the dead of that war and of later ones. Written in response to Carol Ann Duffy's call for poems about the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, 'Poppies' shows that the waiting of families goes on long after the trenches.
In both poems waiting is a form of suffering without end. Owen's soldiers wait to die in a war that seems endless; Weir's parent waits for a voice that may never be heard again.