Remind yourself of 'Walking Away' by Cecil Day-Lewis in your AQA anthology.
Compare how poets present love and loss in 'Walking Away' and in one other poem from 'Love and relationships'.
Model answer
'Walking Away' and 'Eden Rock' both show love bound up with loss, and both picture a loved family member on the far side of a gap. In Day-Lewis's poem a parent loses a child, not to death but to growing up, and comes to see that loss as the proof of love. In Causley's, a speaker who has lost both parents imagines them, young again, waiting across a stream, so that loss seems about to be undone. One poem accepts a loss that is natural and necessary; the other imagines a loss healed by reunion.
The losses differ in kind and scale. Day-Lewis's speaker is honest that this was not the greatest loss of a lifetime: there have been "worse partings". The son is still alive; what has gone is the closeness of early childhood, the moment when a child first moves into a world of his own. Causley's loss is far deeper. Most readers take the parents to be dead, and the opening, "They are waiting for me", suggests a meeting that will come only when the speaker's own life ends. Yet the pain of Day-Lewis's smaller loss is sharper on the surface, while Causley's great loss is told with almost complete calm.
The loved ones are pictured in contrasting ways. Day-Lewis's son is always moving: he drifts, walks and eddies away, and the images of the satellite and the winged seed show him being carried beyond the parent's reach. Causley's parents are still. Time has stopped for them: the father is twenty-five, the mother twenty-three, and even the terrier is "Still two years old". The speaker lingers lovingly on every detail - the mother's hair, "the colour of wheat", the Thermos, the tin cups painted blue - so that love is expressed through the precision of memory. Day-Lewis's love watches someone leave; Causley's holds people exactly as they were.
The direction of movement is reversed. In 'Walking Away' the child moves away from the parent; in 'Eden Rock' the parents call the child towards them. The mother sets out "The same three plates", keeping a place for the speaker, and the parents beckon from the far bank. Both poems use the image of a path. Day-Lewis's boy is like someone who finds no path "where the path should be", lost in a wilderness; Causley's parents call out "See where the stream-path is!" and reassure the speaker that "Crossing is not as hard" as feared. Day-Lewis's parent must leave the son to find his own way; Causley's parents show the way home.
Both poems reach towards the sacred to make sense of loss. Day-Lewis suggests that the parting says roughly "what God alone could perfectly show", placing its meaning beyond human understanding. Causley's title recalls the Garden of Eden, a paradise before the Fall, and the white light of a sky lit as if by three suns makes the scene feel heavenly; the three suns may echo the family of three. The stream that must be crossed recalls the old image of death as a river. For Day-Lewis, God explains why love must let go; for Causley, the afterlife promises that love will be restored.
Form reflects these attitudes. Day-Lewis's ABACA stanzas move from memory to reflection and end in two end-stopped statements of truth, a sign of hard-won acceptance. Causley's quatrains, with gentle half-rhymes, keep the scene calm and balanced, but the poem narrows to a tercet and then to a single line set apart on the page. The white space before it acts like the stream: a gap not yet crossed.
Context deepens both poems. 'Walking Away', addressed to Day-Lewis's eldest son, Sean, and published in 1962, turns a father's private loss into public wisdom. Causley's father died when Causley was seven, from the effects of his service in the First World War, and 'Eden Rock' was published in 1988, when the poet was in his seventies. The parents' youth in the poem reflects how a small child might remember them, and the calm surface carries a lifetime of absence.
The endings bring love and loss together in different ways. Day-Lewis concludes that love is "proved in the letting go": loss is the evidence of love. Causley's speaker admits only "I had not thought" it would be like this, a line of wonder and hesitation that leaves the reunion just ahead. Day-Lewis teaches acceptance of loss; Causley imagines its end.