Remind yourself of 'Follower' by Seamus Heaney in your AQA anthology.
Compare how poets present the land and the seasons in 'Follower' and in one other poem from 'Love and relationships'.
Model answer
'Follower' and Maura Dooley's 'Letters from Yorkshire' both present a man working the land, observed by someone who does not share that work. Heaney's child watches his father plough, and the adult poet records it; Dooley's speaker, a writer working at a screen, receives letters from a man who digs and sows through the Yorkshire seasons. Both poems link the land with something real and rooted, and both quietly question the writer's distance from it. For Heaney, though, the land belongs to memory and family, while for Dooley it is part of a present relationship carried on across a distance.
Each poet presents physical work on the land in close detail. Heaney shows ploughing as a precise craft whose result is perfect: "The sod rolled over without breaking". Dooley's man is seen "In February, digging his garden", planting potatoes, and later breaking the ice on a water butt and clearing a path through snow. Dooley's present participles - digging, planting, breaking, clearing - make the work continuous and repeated, part of an ongoing life, whereas Heaney's memories present one man's skill at its peak.
The seasons are more visible in Dooley's poem. Her man notices "the first lapwings return", a sign of spring, and the speaker pictures him outside "seeing the seasons / turning", the line break itself turning with them. Being in the open air keeps him in step with nature's cycle. Heaney names no season, but ploughing belongs to the farming year, preparing the ground for sowing, and his poem has a cycle of its own: a human one. After five stanzas of childhood, "But today" brings the turn of the generations, as the father who led now stumbles behind. The land in 'Follower' marks time through the ageing of a family rather than the weather.
Both poets show the land in the body. Dooley's man comes indoors to write with "his knuckles singing" as they redden in the warmth, a synaesthetic image that turns pain from the cold into something joyful. Heaney's father works alongside "the sweating team" of horses, his shoulders straining, and the child falls on the "polished sod", soil turned smooth and gleaming by the plough. In both poems the land leaves its mark on those who work it.
The deepest link is the writer's position. Dooley's speaker asks directly, "Is your life more real" because the man digs and sows, and contrasts it with "my heartful of headlines" fed onto a blank screen. The question is half-envious; the man would deny it, but the poem suggests that a life on the land has a solidity that a life of words lacks. Heaney's child longs to plough, yet the adult who writes the poem became a poet, not a farmer, and 'Follower' is itself a way of recording a skill he did not inherit. Both poems are written by people who live by words, looking with admiration at people who live by the land.
Each poem also connects the two worlds. Dooley's letters carry the outdoors to the speaker - the man sends word of that other world, pouring "air and light into an envelope" - and in the final stanza their souls reach each other "across the icy miles". Heaney's connection is with the past: his father, and the farm, follow him into the present and will not go away.
Form reinforces these ideas. 'Letters from Yorkshire' uses five tercets of free verse whose sentences run on across stanza breaks, like a letter or a conversation flowing between two places. 'Follower' uses six regular quatrains with alternate rhyme, as straight and evenly spaced as the furrows the father maps.
Context adds weight to Heaney's side of the comparison. He grew up on the family farm in County Derry, and in 'Digging', the first poem of Death of a Naturalist (1966), he decides to dig with his pen rather than a spade. 'Follower' shares that mixture of admiration for the work of the land and awareness that the poet has chosen another life.
Both poems therefore present the land as real, physical and admirable. Dooley celebrates the seasons through someone else's letters; Heaney celebrates the land through a father whose presence the poet cannot leave behind.