'Edward has every advantage in life, but he never understands the world Mickey lives in.'
How far do you agree with this view of Edward in Blood Brothers?
Write about:
- what Edward says and does
- how far Russell presents Edward as privileged but unable to understand Mickey's world.
[30 marks]
AO4
Model answer
The first half of this statement is clearly true: Edward is given a comfortable home, a private education, a place at university and a career in local politics. The second half is more interesting. As a child, Edward crosses the class divide more easily than anyone else in the play, and he never stops caring about Mickey. As an adult, however, his privilege blinds him to what unemployment means. I largely agree with the view, but I will argue that Russell presents Edward's failure of understanding as a product of his upbringing rather than a lack of kindness.
At seven, the gap between the boys is a source of comedy and fascination. Mickey cannot play in the park because "me mam says"; Edward replies that "my mummy doesn't allow me" to play in Mickey's street. The parallel lines show two children under the same kind of rule, separated only by vocabulary. Edward hands over his sweets without a second thought, which baffles Mickey, and he is thrilled by Mickey's swearing: "Oh, that sounds like super fun". When he is amazed that Mickey does not know what a dictionary is, he sounds curious rather than superior. Russell suggests that Edward genuinely wants to enter Mickey's world, and the blood-brother pact shows how completely he embraces it.
His innocence about money appears early. Visiting Mrs Johnstone before his family moves to the country, he asks why she does not simply "buy a new house near us", as if housing were a matter of choice. The line is touching but revealing: Edward has never had to think about what things cost. Even so, he cries because he does not want to leave Mickey, and he keeps the locket for years, refusing to give it up at school and accepting suspension instead. His loyalty is never in doubt.
As teenagers, the two envy each other in 'That Guy', each imagining the other has the confidence he lacks. Edward also shows real generosity: although he loves Linda, he persuades Mickey to ask her out and hides his own feelings in 'I'm Not Saying a Word'. Here he seems to understand Mickey's shyness better than Mickey does.
The Christmas scene is where the statement becomes most convincing. Edward returns from university full of "so many parties" and cannot see why Mickey is so flat. When Mickey explains that he has spent months looking for work, Edward says he would simply "live like a bohemian" and "tilt my hat to the world". Mickey's reply, that he has no hat he could "tilt at the world", exposes the gap: carefree rebellion is a luxury for people with a safety net. Edward's offer - "I've got money, plenty of it" - is meant kindly, but it humiliates Mickey, who throws the notes to the ground. When Edward protests that he thought they were "blood brothers", he cannot see that the pact means nothing to a man who has lost his job. Russell makes Edward's generosity the clearest sign of his ignorance.
As a councillor, Edward finds the couple a house and Mickey a job. Again his kindness is real, but it places Mickey in his debt, and his growing closeness to Linda shows how little he grasps what Mickey has lost. In the final scene he greets the man pointing a gun at him with a quiet "Hello, Mickey" and insists "Linda and I are just friends". He dies still trying to talk his way through a crisis that words cannot solve.
The context explains why Russell shapes Edward this way. Private schools and universities opened doors that stayed closed to most working-class teenagers in the 1970s, and in the early 1980s the people making decisions for communities like Mickey's were rarely the ones losing their jobs. Edward, the councillor, belongs to that world without ever choosing to.
Overall, I agree that Edward never fully understands Mickey's adult world, but Russell does not present him as selfish. His blindness is what privilege teaches, and that is the point: the same boy, given Mickey's life, would have been Mickey. Russell turns Edward's innocence into an argument about class rather than a verdict on a character.