Remind yourself of 'On an Afternoon Train from Purley to Victoria, 1955' by James Berry in your AQA anthology.
Compare how poets present a sense of time and place in 'On an Afternoon Train from Purley to Victoria, 1955' and in one other poem from 'Worlds and lives'.
Model answer
Both 'On an Afternoon Train from Purley to Victoria, 1955' and 'A Wider View' are rooted in precise times and places, and both show that a single place can hold more than one time. Berry's title fixes an afternoon, a route and a year, yet his speaker's mind slips to dawn streets and to his father's field far away. Seneviratne names the streets and buildings of Leeds and the year 1869, then lets time collapse so that she can stand beside her ancestor. Both poets use a specific moment to explore heritage, and both end with the word "us".
The poets fix their settings with documentary precision. Berry's title reads almost like a diary entry or a caption: the train, the stations and the date. The year matters, because it places the poem in post-war Britain, when Caribbean migrants were arriving and settling. Seneviratne opens a stanza with "In eighteen sixty-nine" and fills her poem with real names - Marshall's Temple Mill, Tower Works, Neville Street, the River Aire - so Leeds becomes a map of history. Both poets insist that their stories happened somewhere real.
Yet both places are layered with other times. In the middle of an afternoon conversation, Berry's speaker sees "empty city streets" "in a day's first hours", so dawn appears inside the afternoon, and beside it lies "my father's big banana field". London and Jamaica, present and past, exist side by side in his mind. Seneviratne's layering is more deliberate. Her first three stanzas imagine her great-great-grandfather's long day of "twelve hours combing flax"; then a stanza set in the present day begins, and there "time, collapsing" in the river sweeps her out to meet him. Berry's layers are involuntary - "Inexplicably I saw" - while Seneviratne's are summoned by imagination.
Both poems show people reaching beyond the place they are in. Seneviratne's ancestor "searched for spaces" in the smoky sky and, passing a factory chimney, heard "imagined peals of ringing bells", escaping the noise of the mill in his mind. Berry's speaker escapes the train carriage in the same way, into a vision of home. Both men are working people in industrial cities whose inner lives travel far beyond their surroundings.
The endings bring time and place together through relationships. Seneviratne ends with herself and her ancestor standing "timeless in the flux of time", while the curve of the generations "arcs between us". Berry ends as "people sat down around us", the carriage filling and the present moment closing in. Both final images use "us", but differently: Seneviratne's joins two people separated by a century, while Berry's joins two strangers for a moment before the crowd returns. One poem dissolves time; the other returns firmly to it.
Form reflects these approaches. Berry's free verse follows the conversation in the order it happened, so time moves forward like the train, interrupted only by the vision. Seneviratne's five stanzas divide past and present, three for 1869 and two for today, with a full stop marking the break between the centuries; yet within the stanzas her long, enjambed sentences flow freely, and the image of time collapsing undoes the division her structure sets up.
Context adds weight to each place. Berry came to Britain from Jamaica in 1948, one of the Windrush generation, and in 1955 Jamaica was still a British colony; his train journey captures a particular moment in the history of migration to Britain. Seneviratne, born and raised in Leeds and of Sri Lankan heritage, writes about the industrial town of her ancestor, so her sense of place is also a sense of belonging to a family history.
Both poets therefore treat time and place as inseparable from identity. Berry shows one afternoon in which a migrant carries another place and time inside him; Seneviratne shows a city in which past and present generations meet.