Remind yourself of 'Before You Were Mine' by Carol Ann Duffy in your AQA anthology.
Compare how poets present youth and its loss in 'Before You Were Mine' and in one other poem from 'Love and relationships'.
Model answer
'Before You Were Mine' and Charlotte Mew's 'The Farmer's Bride' both present young women whose youth is lost to a role imposed on them - motherhood in Duffy's poem, marriage in Mew's - and both are spoken by someone who lays claim to them: Duffy's title claims the mother, and Mew's farmer begins, "Three Summers since I chose a maid". Yet the losses differ. Duffy's mother enjoyed a youth of laughter, dancing and freedom, and although motherhood ended it, its glamour survives in memory. Mew's bride had her youth taken from her almost at once by a marriage she feared, and her wild young spirit survives only when she escapes among animals, out of her husband's reach.
The youth of each woman is presented through vivid imagery. Duffy's mother is noisy and glamorous: she laughs on a street corner with her pals, dances in the ballroom and is compared to Marilyn Monroe. Mew's bride is described through the natural world: she is "Shy as a leveret, swift as he, / Straight and slight as a young larch tree, / Sweet as the first wild violets". The similes of young animals, saplings and early flowers suggest innocence, freshness and wildness. Duffy's youth is urban, sociable and sophisticated; Mew's is rural, solitary and natural.
Each poem identifies the point at which youth was lost. For Duffy's mother it was the child's birth, which ended the decade before "my loud, possessive yell". In the second stanza "I'm not here yet", and the mother can risk a hiding for staying out late - "You reckon it's worth it" - because she has only herself to answer for. For Mew's bride the loss came with the wedding: "When us was wed she turned afraid". Her smile went out "Like the shut of a winter's day", a simile that makes her youth vanish as suddenly as winter daylight. Duffy's mother had years of freedom before the change; Mew's bride had almost none, since the farmer admits she was "Too young maybe".
What remains of youth is presented differently. Duffy's mother's youth survives in objects and memories: the high-heeled red shoes have become "relics", sacred remains of a lost life, and her ghost "clatters" across George Square towards the speaker. In the end, "That glamorous love lasts" in the speaker's imagination. Mew's bride keeps her youth alive only in secret, chatting and playing with "birds and rabbits" so long as the men keep away. Her youthful self survives, but only "To her wild self", in a world the farmer cannot enter.
The speakers' attitudes to the lost youth differ. Duffy's speaker admires the young mother and feels guilty about the child's part in ending her freedom. Mew's farmer is partly sympathetic - "Alone, poor maid" - but his feelings turn into frustrated desire for "The soft young down of her", so the bride's youth is something he wants rather than something he mourns on her behalf. Duffy's speaker longs to give the mother back her freedom; Mew's farmer longs to possess the youth he has frightened away.
Time and the seasons frame each loss. Mew's farmer measures his marriage in summers and in the turning of the year: "The short days shorten and the oaks are brown", and the berries redden towards Christmas, reminders of time passing in an empty home. Duffy moves between the mother's youth, the speaker's childhood and the present, so the lost youth is seen across several decades at once.
Form reflects the two speakers. 'The Farmer's Bride' is a dramatic monologue in the farmer's dialect, with rhyme and irregular stanzas, and its final lines break into fragments - "her eyes, her hair, her hair!" - as desire overwhelms him. 'Before You Were Mine' uses four five-line stanzas of free verse and an affectionate, chatty voice that ends calmly, insisting that the mother's youth lives on.
Context adds depth. Mew's poem, published in 1916 in her collection The Farmer's Bride, presents a rural marriage in which a very young woman seems to have had little say. Duffy's poem, often read as autobiographical, explores the freedom a woman loses when she has a child, and it imagines her mother's youth in Glasgow in the decade before Duffy was born in 1955.
Both poems mourn a young woman's lost freedom. Duffy celebrates a youth that was fully lived and is lovingly remembered; Mew presents one that was cut short, surviving only in a wildness that no one can reach.