Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
AQA GCSE English Literature (Paper 2) Smart practice A mixed round aimed at your weak spots
Unit 1
Section A: Modern prose or drama
Unit 2
Section B: Poetry - Love and relationships
Unit 3
Section B: Poetry - Power and conflict
Unit 4
Section B: Poetry - Worlds and lives
Unit 5
Section C: Unseen poetry
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/59

Before You Were Mine (Carol Ann Duffy)

Practise 18 exam-style questions on Before You Were Mine (Carol Ann Duffy) for AQA GCSE English Literature (Paper 2). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 18 questions
  • 1–30 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
18 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

3 marks

In 'Before You Were Mine', the speaker imagines the mother's life before the speaker was born.

Give three things the speaker imagines the mother doing before the speaker was born.

Model answer

She laughs on a street corner with her pals, dances in the ballroom, and comes home late even though her Ma is waiting with a hiding.

Explanation

The speaker imagines a mother full of energy, friendship, romance and mild rebellion - laughing, dancing, staying out late and "winking" boldly in Portobello. Duffy has said that these images came from old photographs and from her mother's stories of dancing in Glasgow. The contrast with the speaker's "loud, possessive yell" shows what motherhood later changed. Students sometimes include the dance steps on the way home from Mass, which belong to the speaker's own childhood.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    laughing (on a street corner) with her pals / friends (Maggie McGeeney and Jean Duff)

    max 3: one mark for each different activity. Short quotations or paraphrases are equally acceptable. Do not credit things from the speaker's own childhood, which come after the birth: teaching the speaker dance steps on the way home from Mass, or the speaker playing with the red shoes. Do not accept 'looking at photographs' or 'being a mother'.

  2. 1 mark

    bending from the waist / holding each other or her knees / shrieking at the pavement

  3. 1 mark

    posing like Marilyn (Monroe) / her (polka-dot) dress blowing round her legs

  4. 1 mark

    dancing (in the ballroom)

  5. 1 mark

    staying out late / walking home late and risking a hiding from her Ma

  6. 1 mark

    being kissed / getting love bites ('small bites on your neck') under the tree with its lights

  7. 1 mark

    winking in Portobello / being a bold girl

  8. 1 mark

    sparkling, waltzing and laughing

Question 2

8 marks

Remind yourself of 'Before You Were Mine' by Carol Ann Duffy in your AQA anthology.

In 'Before You Were Mine', how does Duffy present the speaker's own childhood memories in the third and fourth stanzas?

Model answer

In the third and fourth stanzas Duffy presents the speaker's own childhood memories as joyful and vivid, but tinged with a sense of loss, because even as a child the speaker was fascinated by the mother's earlier life.

The first memory is intimate and physical: "I remember my hands" in the mother's "high-heeled red shoes, relics". The image of a small child playing in grown-up shoes is affectionate and comic, but it also suggests a child trying on the mother's past. The word "relics", set off by commas, is striking: relics are sacred remains, kept in memory of something that has gone. The red shoes, symbols of glamour and passion, now belong to a vanished life, and the child treasures them almost religiously.

The final stanza opens with an exclamation, "Cha cha cha!", which brings the rhythm of a dance into the poem and fills it with energy. The mother, it seems, never lost her spirit: "You'd teach me the steps" on the way home from Mass. Setting the dancing after church contrasts the seriousness of religion with the mother's playfulness, and the image of "stamping stars from the wrong pavement" turns the sparks from their shoes into something magical. "Wrong" may hint at a small act of rebellion, as mother and child dance where they should not.

Yet these happy memories carry longing. "Even then", the speaker admits, "I wanted the bold girl" from the mother's youth. The child loved the mother, but already sensed that there had been an earlier, freer woman whom the child could never know.

Duffy therefore presents childhood memories that are warm and lively, but shadowed by the knowledge that the mother's most glamorous days belonged to a time before the speaker existed.

Explanation

Top answers analyse the red shoes as "relics", the energy of "Cha cha cha!" and the magic of "stamping stars", and then show how "Even then" reveals the child's longing for the mother's past. They balance the joy of the memories with the sense of loss. Answers that retell the memories without analysing language, or that confuse the speaker's childhood with the mother's youth, stay in the lower levels.

Mark scheme
  1. 8 marks

    Levels of response (8 marks). AO1 (4 marks), AO2 (4 marks). A short practice task: four levels adapted from AQA's descriptors.
    Level 4 (7-8 marks): Convincing, critical analysis and exploration, or thoughtful, developed consideration. A critical or thoughtful, developed response to the task; precise references integrated into interpretation; analysis of the writer's methods and their effects, with subject terminology used judiciously.
    Level 3 (5-6 marks): Clear understanding. A clear, explained response; effective use of references; clear explanation of the writer's methods and understanding of their effects, with appropriate subject terminology.
    Level 2 (3-4 marks): Explained, structured comments. Some explained response; references support relevant comments; explained comments on the writer's methods, identifying some effects, with some relevant terminology.
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): Supported, relevant comments, or simple, explicit comments. Simple or supported comments relevant to the task; reference to relevant details; awareness or identification of the writer's choices.
    0 marks: nothing to reward.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): AO1: the childhood memories are affectionate, playful and vivid, showing that the mother kept some of her youthful spirit; they also reveal the child's early fascination with the mother's past and a sense of having missed her best years; the memories mix joy with loss. AO2: "I remember my hands" (direct, personal memory); "high-heeled red shoes, relics" (glamour; the child trying on the mother's past; "relics" - sacred remains of a vanished life); "your ghost clatters" (the sound of heels; the past returning); "Cha cha cha!" (exclamation, dance rhythm, joy); "You'd teach me the steps" (passing on her love of dancing); "on the way home from Mass" (religion and rule-keeping set against play); "stamping stars from the wrong pavement" (sparks from shoes; magic; mild rebellion); "Even then" and "I wanted the bold girl" (the child already longing for the mother's former self). Context may be used: Duffy's family moved from Glasgow to Stafford, in England, when she was six, and some readers link "the wrong pavement" to that move (credit as interpretation). Marking note: the poem does not say where the walk home from Mass takes place; do not credit a stated location as fact.

Question 3

30 marks

Remind yourself of 'Before You Were Mine' by Carol Ann Duffy in your AQA anthology.

Compare how poets present celebrating someone you love in 'Before You Were Mine' and in one other poem from 'Love and relationships'.

Model answer

'Before You Were Mine' and Andrew Waterhouse's 'Climbing My Grandfather' both celebrate a loved older relative, and both build that celebration from vivid physical detail. Duffy celebrates a mother's glamour, energy and freedom as a young woman; Waterhouse celebrates a grandfather's ageing body and the goodness within it. Duffy's celebration is of someone at her most dazzling, mixed with possessiveness and a sense of loss; Waterhouse's is of someone old and weathered, and it ends in quiet, intimate love.

Each poet celebrates a different kind of beauty. Duffy's mother is a star: the one-word sentence "Marilyn." compares her to Marilyn Monroe, and she is remembered dancing, laughing and flirting. Waterhouse celebrates a body marked by age and work, beginning with the "old brogues, dusty and cracked" and moving to an earth-stained hand with splintered nails. The skin of the grandfather's finger is "like warm ice", an oxymoron that captures both smooth hardness and human warmth. Duffy celebrates youth; Waterhouse finds beauty in age.

Both poets celebrate through the senses. Duffy fills her poem with sound and movement: the young women "shriek at the pavement", the mother's ghost clatters across George Square, and she appears "clear as scent", a synaesthetic simile that blends sight and smell. Waterhouse's celebration is mainly tactile: the speaker feels the weave of the trousers, the ridge of a scar, the grandfather's heat. This close physical attention is itself a form of love, as if celebrating someone means learning every detail of them.

Joy and energy run through Duffy's celebration. The final stanza bursts in with "Cha cha cha!" as the mother teaches the child dance steps on the way home from Mass, and she is "the bold girl winking" in Portobello. Waterhouse's celebration is calmer and built on trust: the speaker climbs without rope or net, rests at the firm shoulder, and pauses at "a smiling mouth". The grandfather's smile, like the mother's laughter, shows the warmth the speakers love.

Both celebrations are aware of time. Duffy celebrates the mother as she was before the speaker's birth, and the speaker admits that her best years came before the child, so the celebration is tinged with guilt and longing. Waterhouse's grandfather is old: his hair is "soft and white" at the summit, and his pulse is slow. Yet Waterhouse turns these signs of age into part of the celebration rather than a cause for sadness.

The endings bring each celebration to its height. Duffy insists that the mother's glamorous love lasts where she will always "sparkle and waltz and laugh", a list of verbs linked by repeated conjunctions that keeps her moving for ever in the speaker's imagination. Waterhouse ends in stillness and intimacy: lying at the summit, watching clouds and birds, the speaker feels the "slow pulse of his good heart". The final word moves the celebration from the grandfather's body to his character.

Form shapes the two celebrations. Duffy's four five-line stanzas of free verse move between times, as if turning the pages of a photograph album. Waterhouse's single unbroken stanza follows one continuous climb, its enjambment carrying the reader upward towards the summit and the heart.

Context adds depth. The poem is often read as a love poem to Duffy's own mother, drawn from old photographs and from her mother's stories of dancing in Glasgow before Duffy was born in 1955. Waterhouse's poem, from his first collection, In (2000), turns a grandfather into a whole landscape, celebrating an older generation whose bodies carry the marks of long lives.

Both poems celebrate a loved relative with admiration and tenderness. Duffy celebrates a dazzling past that the speaker can only imagine; Waterhouse celebrates a closeness in the present, earned through the effort of the climb.

Explanation

Strong answers compare what each poet celebrates (youthful glamour, or an ageing body and a good heart), how the senses are used, the awareness of time in both, and the contrasting endings - endless movement and quiet stillness. Analysis of methods such as the one-word sentence "Marilyn.", synaesthesia, oxymoron and the extended climbing metaphor keeps the comparison precise. Avoid simply listing admiring words from each poem.

Mark scheme
  1. 30 marks

    Levels of response (30 marks). AO1 12, AO2 12, AO3 6. Rubric (AQA): where a response is judged not to have addressed a defining feature of the task (a response to the named poem and one other from the named cluster), this would be classed as a rubric infringement and could be 'capped' at the top of Level 2.
    Level 6 (26-30 marks): Convincing, critical analysis and exploration. A critical, exploratory comparison; judicious, precise references; analysis of the writers' methods and their effects, with judicious subject terminology; exploration of ideas/perspectives/contextual factors through specific, detailed links between context/text/task.
    Level 5 (21-25 marks): Thoughtful, developed consideration. A thoughtful, developed comparison; apt references integrated into interpretation; examination of the writers' methods and their effects, with effective subject terminology; thoughtful consideration of ideas/perspectives/context through detailed links.
    Level 4 (16-20 marks): Clear understanding. A clear comparison; effective use of references; clear explanation of the writers' methods and their effects, with appropriate subject terminology; clear understanding of ideas/perspectives/context through specific links.
    Level 3 (11-15 marks): Explained, structured comments. Some explained comparison; references support a range of relevant comments; explained comments on the writers' methods and some effects, with some relevant terminology; some understanding of implicit ideas/context.
    Level 2 (6-10 marks): Supported, relevant comments. A supported comparison; comments on references; identification of the writers' methods, with some subject terminology; some awareness of implicit ideas/context.
    Level 1 (1-5 marks): Simple, explicit comments. Simple comments relevant to comparison; reference to relevant detail(s); awareness of the writer making choices; simple comment on explicit ideas/context.
    0 marks: nothing to reward.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): AO1: both poems celebrate a loved older relative through vivid physical detail; Duffy celebrates the mother's glamour, energy and freedom as a young woman, with possessiveness and a sense of loss; Waterhouse celebrates a grandfather's ageing, weathered body and the goodness within it, ending in quiet intimacy; Duffy celebrates youth, Waterhouse finds beauty in age; both celebrations are aware of time. AO2: 'Before You Were Mine' - "Marilyn."; "shriek at the pavement"; the ghost that clatters; "clear as scent" (synaesthesia); "Cha cha cha!"; "the bold girl winking"; "sparkle and waltz and laugh" (a list of verbs); four five-line stanzas of free verse, shifting time frames. 'Climbing My Grandfather' - the extended metaphor of climbing; "old brogues, dusty and cracked"; "like warm ice" (oxymoron); the earth-stained hand and scar; climbing without rope or net (trust); "a smiling mouth"; "soft and white"; "slow pulse of his good heart"; one unbroken stanza, present tense, enjambment. AO3: the poem is often read as a love poem to Duffy's own mother, drawn from old photographs and stories of dancing in Glasgow before Duffy's birth in 1955; Waterhouse's first collection, In (2000); ideas about admiration, idealisation and ageing. Other good partners: 'Follower' (admiring a father's skill), 'Eden Rock' (young parents lovingly remembered), 'Sonnet 29' (celebrating a beloved). Marking note: the speaker's gender is not stated in either poem.

Question 4

30 marks

Remind yourself of 'Before You Were Mine' by Carol Ann Duffy in your AQA anthology.

Compare how poets present youth and its loss in 'Before You Were Mine' and in one other poem from 'Love and relationships'.

Model answer

'Before You Were Mine' and Charlotte Mew's 'The Farmer's Bride' both present young women whose youth is lost to a role imposed on them - motherhood in Duffy's poem, marriage in Mew's - and both are spoken by someone who lays claim to them: Duffy's title claims the mother, and Mew's farmer begins, "Three Summers since I chose a maid". Yet the losses differ. Duffy's mother enjoyed a youth of laughter, dancing and freedom, and although motherhood ended it, its glamour survives in memory. Mew's bride had her youth taken from her almost at once by a marriage she feared, and her wild young spirit survives only when she escapes among animals, out of her husband's reach.

The youth of each woman is presented through vivid imagery. Duffy's mother is noisy and glamorous: she laughs on a street corner with her pals, dances in the ballroom and is compared to Marilyn Monroe. Mew's bride is described through the natural world: she is "Shy as a leveret, swift as he, / Straight and slight as a young larch tree, / Sweet as the first wild violets". The similes of young animals, saplings and early flowers suggest innocence, freshness and wildness. Duffy's youth is urban, sociable and sophisticated; Mew's is rural, solitary and natural.

Each poem identifies the point at which youth was lost. For Duffy's mother it was the child's birth, which ended the decade before "my loud, possessive yell". In the second stanza "I'm not here yet", and the mother can risk a hiding for staying out late - "You reckon it's worth it" - because she has only herself to answer for. For Mew's bride the loss came with the wedding: "When us was wed she turned afraid". Her smile went out "Like the shut of a winter's day", a simile that makes her youth vanish as suddenly as winter daylight. Duffy's mother had years of freedom before the change; Mew's bride had almost none, since the farmer admits she was "Too young maybe".

What remains of youth is presented differently. Duffy's mother's youth survives in objects and memories: the high-heeled red shoes have become "relics", sacred remains of a lost life, and her ghost "clatters" across George Square towards the speaker. In the end, "That glamorous love lasts" in the speaker's imagination. Mew's bride keeps her youth alive only in secret, chatting and playing with "birds and rabbits" so long as the men keep away. Her youthful self survives, but only "To her wild self", in a world the farmer cannot enter.

The speakers' attitudes to the lost youth differ. Duffy's speaker admires the young mother and feels guilty about the child's part in ending her freedom. Mew's farmer is partly sympathetic - "Alone, poor maid" - but his feelings turn into frustrated desire for "The soft young down of her", so the bride's youth is something he wants rather than something he mourns on her behalf. Duffy's speaker longs to give the mother back her freedom; Mew's farmer longs to possess the youth he has frightened away.

Time and the seasons frame each loss. Mew's farmer measures his marriage in summers and in the turning of the year: "The short days shorten and the oaks are brown", and the berries redden towards Christmas, reminders of time passing in an empty home. Duffy moves between the mother's youth, the speaker's childhood and the present, so the lost youth is seen across several decades at once.

Form reflects the two speakers. 'The Farmer's Bride' is a dramatic monologue in the farmer's dialect, with rhyme and irregular stanzas, and its final lines break into fragments - "her eyes, her hair, her hair!" - as desire overwhelms him. 'Before You Were Mine' uses four five-line stanzas of free verse and an affectionate, chatty voice that ends calmly, insisting that the mother's youth lives on.

Context adds depth. Mew's poem, published in 1916 in her collection The Farmer's Bride, presents a rural marriage in which a very young woman seems to have had little say. Duffy's poem, often read as autobiographical, explores the freedom a woman loses when she has a child, and it imagines her mother's youth in Glasgow in the decade before Duffy was born in 1955.

Both poems mourn a young woman's lost freedom. Duffy celebrates a youth that was fully lived and is lovingly remembered; Mew presents one that was cut short, surviving only in a wildness that no one can reach.

Explanation

High-level answers compare how each poet presents youth (glamour and sociability, or wild natural innocence), the moment it was lost (birth, or marriage), what survives of it, and the speakers' different attitudes - admiration and guilt, or pity and desire. Close analysis of Mew's natural similes alongside Duffy's "relics" and ghost keeps the comparison precise. Avoid treating both speakers as equally sympathetic, and avoid inventing a date for the mother's youth beyond the decade before Duffy's birth.

Mark scheme
  1. 30 marks

    Levels of response (30 marks). AO1 12, AO2 12, AO3 6. Rubric (AQA): where a response is judged not to have addressed a defining feature of the task (a response to the named poem and one other from the named cluster), this would be classed as a rubric infringement and could be 'capped' at the top of Level 2.
    Level 6 (26-30 marks): Convincing, critical analysis and exploration. A critical, exploratory comparison; judicious, precise references; analysis of the writers' methods and their effects, with judicious subject terminology; exploration of ideas/perspectives/contextual factors through specific, detailed links between context/text/task.
    Level 5 (21-25 marks): Thoughtful, developed consideration. A thoughtful, developed comparison; apt references integrated into interpretation; examination of the writers' methods and their effects, with effective subject terminology; thoughtful consideration of ideas/perspectives/context through detailed links.
    Level 4 (16-20 marks): Clear understanding. A clear comparison; effective use of references; clear explanation of the writers' methods and their effects, with appropriate subject terminology; clear understanding of ideas/perspectives/context through specific links.
    Level 3 (11-15 marks): Explained, structured comments. Some explained comparison; references support a range of relevant comments; explained comments on the writers' methods and some effects, with some relevant terminology; some understanding of implicit ideas/context.
    Level 2 (6-10 marks): Supported, relevant comments. A supported comparison; comments on references; identification of the writers' methods, with some subject terminology; some awareness of implicit ideas/context.
    Level 1 (1-5 marks): Simple, explicit comments. Simple comments relevant to comparison; reference to relevant detail(s); awareness of the writer making choices; simple comment on explicit ideas/context.
    0 marks: nothing to reward.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): AO1: both poems present young women whose youth is lost to a role imposed on them - motherhood in Duffy's poem, marriage in Mew's - and both are spoken by someone who lays claim to them; Duffy's mother had years of laughter, dancing and freedom, whose glamour survives in memory; Mew's bride had her youth cut short almost at once by a marriage she feared, and it survives only in her wildness among animals; Duffy's speaker admires and feels guilty, Mew's farmer pities and desires. AO2: 'Before You Were Mine' - the mother's glamorous youth (the corner, the ballroom, "Marilyn."); "I'm not here yet"; "You reckon it's worth it"; the decade before "my loud, possessive yell"; "relics"; the ghost that "clatters"; "That glamorous love lasts"; time shifts, free verse. 'The Farmer's Bride' - "Three Summers since I chose a maid"; "Too young maybe"; "When us was wed she turned afraid"; "Her smile went out" like "the shut of a winter's day"; natural similes ("Shy as a leveret", "Sweet as the first wild violets"); "To her wild self"; "Alone, poor maid"; "The soft young down of her"; seasonal imagery ("The short days shorten"); dramatic monologue in dialect, rhyme, irregular stanzas, the fragmented ending. AO3: Mew's poem published in 1916 in her collection The Farmer's Bride - a rural marriage in which a very young woman seems to have had little say; Duffy's poem, often read as autobiographical, explores the freedom a woman loses when she has a child, imagining her mother's youth in Glasgow in the decade before Duffy's birth in 1955. Other good partners: 'Eden Rock' (parents preserved young), 'Walking Away' (a child's youth and independence), 'Porphyria's Lover' (a young woman possessed). Marking note: do not credit the claim that Duffy's mother's youth was 'in the 1950s' as fact - the poem imagines the decade before Duffy's birth in 1955.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.