Remind yourself of 'Storm on the Island' by Seamus Heaney in your AQA anthology.
Compare how poets present feelings that are held back in 'Storm on the Island' and in one other poem from 'Power and conflict'.
Model answer
Both 'Storm on the Island' and 'Poppies' present feelings that are held back rather than openly expressed, above all anxiety about a danger that the speaker cannot control. But the danger and the anxiety are of different kinds. Heaney's islanders share a practical anxiety about a storm they know will come, and in the end it breaks through their composure. Weir's speaker feels the private anxiety of a parent whose child is leaving home, possibly for war, and it seeps out through the details of the poem rather than being stated.
Both speakers try to suppress what they feel. Heaney's islanders do so through preparation and a steady, confident tone, and when the storm comes "We just sit tight", a colloquial phrase that suggests nerves held steady by will alone. Weir's speaker suppresses tenderness rather than fear: the speaker "steeled the softening" of the face and "resisted the impulse" to run fingers through the child's hair. The enjambment after "softening" leaves the face hanging between hardness and collapse, mirroring the effort of self-control. Both poems present anxiety as something that must be hidden - by the islanders to keep their courage, by the parent to let the child go without a scene.
The sources of anxiety are presented differently. Heaney's threat is vast but impersonal: the wind "strafes invisibly", and its invisibility makes it harder to bear, because there is nothing to watch and nothing to fight. Weir's anxiety centres on one beloved person, and the danger is never named. The poem opens with poppies already placed on "individual war graves" and ends at a war memorial, so the possibility of death in war frames everything, yet the poem never says what has happened to the child. In both poems an unseen or unspoken threat creates more anxiety than a visible one would.
The poets find very different images for anxiety. Weir uses domestic and textile imagery. The speaker's words are "flattened, rolled, turned into felt", as if feelings have been pressed into silence, and later the speaker's stomach is busy making "tucks, darts, pleats", turning nervousness into the movements of sewing, a homely image for a knot of worry. Heaney uses sound and violence: the hissing sibilance of the final lines makes the gale audible, and the speaker's list of absences - no hay, no trees, "no natural shelter" - leaves the islanders with nothing to hold on to.
Both speakers listen, and in both the wind carries their anxiety. Heaney's speaker imagines how trees would let people "listen to the thing you fear", but on the treeless island the storm has no voice to distract them from its blows. Weir's poem ends with the speaker at the memorial, hoping to hear the child's "playground voice catching on the wind". The wind is the source of fear in one poem and the carrier of longing in the other, and both speakers strain towards something that is not there.
Neither poem resolves its anxiety. Heaney's final line, with its pause on "Strange", admits a fear that breaks the islanders' composure while the storm still rages. Weir's ending is suspended between hope and grief: the speaker leans against the memorial "like a wishbone", a simile suggesting both a wish and something about to snap. Form supports this. Heaney's ordered blank verse is contained until the short sentences of the storm break it up; Weir's long, enjambed free verse sentences run on breathlessly, like anxious thoughts that cannot be stopped.
Context gives both poems a wider meaning. 'Poppies' is set at the time of remembrance - the poppies, Armistice Sunday and the war memorial connect one parent's anxiety to every family that has lost someone in war. Heaney's poem, from Death of a Naturalist (1966), presents a community's anxiety about the weather, but its military imagery and the possible pun on Stormont have led some readers to see it as an image of a community's anxiety about political violence.
Both poets show that anxiety is hardest to bear when the threat cannot be seen or named. Heaney's islanders share their fear and finally admit it together; Weir's speaker bears it alone, hidden behind the small, ordinary actions of a parent. One poem ends in fear of "a huge nothing", the other in the hope of hearing a voice that may be gone for ever.