Remind yourself of 'pot' by shamshad khan in your AQA anthology.
Compare how poets present the effects of history in 'pot' and in one other poem from 'Worlds and lives'.
Model answer
Both 'pot' and 'A Wider View' show the past living on in English cities, inside buildings that hold history: a museum in Manchester and the industrial streets of Leeds. Both speakers turn to that past to understand who they are. Yet the effects of history are opposite. In 'pot' history divides: a colonial past has separated an object, and by implication people, from where they belong, leaving gaps that no one will fill. In 'A Wider View' history connects: the speaker's walk through Leeds leads to a meeting with a great-great-grandad who worked there in 1869.
The poets approach history with very different amounts of knowledge. khan's speaker admits to knowing "half of the story" and has to ask the pot for the rest; the accounts supplied by others are evasive, and one of them, "a looters' deal done", suggests theft dressed up as trade. History here is incomplete and controlled by those who benefited from it. Seneviratne, by contrast, recreates the past in precise detail: the year written out in full, "twelve hours combing flax", and named landmarks such as Marshall's Temple Mill and Harding's chimney at Tower Works, real buildings in the Holbeck area of Leeds. Her imagination works on solid knowledge, filling exactly the kind of gap that khan's speaker cannot.
Both poems show history's effects on ordinary lives. In 'A Wider View' the industrial town is harsh: the ancestor lives in a back-to-back house, the sky is "smoke-filled", and he hopes to keep his newborn safe "above the cholera". Leeds suffered cholera epidemics in the nineteenth century, and its cramped back-to-back terraces were notoriously dark and badly ventilated, so these details root the poem in real suffering. In 'pot' the effects fall on the people who lost the pot, who "will have missed you", the future perfect imagining grief that echoes down the years. They fall, too, on the speaker, whose own fear of rejection is projected onto the pot: "you're not really one of us". Colonial history, the poem suggests, still shapes who feels they belong.
Buildings hold history in both poems, but they behave differently. The museum's glass preserves the pot and imprisons it; the dedication even calls it "incarcerated". Seneviratne's architecture speaks. In the Dark Arches beneath Leeds station, completed in 1869, the very year of the ancestor's walk, the "red-brick vaults / begin to moan", a personification that makes the city remember its past aloud. Speaker and ancestor are finally held together by a shared gaze at a tower with "gilded tiles", the dust-extraction chimney at Tower Works that imitates Giotto's bell tower in Florence: industry has left beauty behind as well as hardship. In khan's poem the institution silences; in Seneviratne's the buildings are witnesses.
Structure enacts each poem's view of time. Seneviratne gives three stanzas to 1869 and two to the present, but the boundary dissolves: "time, collapsing" in the river sweeps the speaker out to meet the ancestor, and the final image of generations that "arcs between us" presents history as a bridge. The short last line settles like the keystone of an arch. 'pot' moves restlessly between the museum, the imagined past, the speaker's own visit and an imagined return, and its fragments never resolve: it ends with two unanswered questions, "pot?", leaving history's effects unfinished.
Context makes the contrast pointed. khan, a British poet of Pakistani heritage, wrote 'pot' for the Manchester Museum, and it reflects debates about objects taken during the British Empire; Nigeria, the pot's home, was a British colony until 1960. Seneviratne, of English and Sri Lankan heritage and raised in Leeds, writes the city's industrial past into her own family story. Both poets, in different ways, ask who British history belongs to, and both suggest that it belongs to more people than official accounts allow.
In the end 'A Wider View' finds in history a source of strength and belonging, while 'pot' finds an injury that is still open. Seneviratne's speaker can meet the past; khan's can only call to it and wait.