Remind yourself of 'Checking Out Me History' by John Agard in your AQA anthology.
Compare how poets present the importance of truth in 'Checking Out Me History' and in one other poem from 'Power and conflict'.
Model answer
Both 'War Photographer' and 'Checking Out Me History' insist that truth matters, and both are angry at the way it is filtered before it reaches people. Duffy's photographer captures the truth of war, but an editor chooses a handful of images and readers glance at them and forget. Agard's speaker was given a selected truth by a curriculum that left out whole peoples. Duffy ends in bitterness that the truth changes nothing; Agard ends with the speaker going in search of it.
In both poems truth is cut down by those who control what the public sees. Duffy's photographer brings home "A hundred agonies" in black and white, from which his editor will "pick out five or six" for a Sunday supplement. The numbers show how much suffering is discarded. Agard's teachers are just as selective: the speaker was told "Wha dem want to tell me". Both poets present gatekeepers, an editor and an education system, who decide which truths are worth knowing, and both suggest that what is left out matters most.
The poems show different costs when truth is filtered. For Duffy, the cost is sympathy. The readers' "eyeballs prick / with tears", but only briefly, between a bath and drinks before lunch, and the poem's final verdict is "they do not care". The truth reaches them but does not change them. For Agard, the cost is identity: a partial history would "Blind me to me own identity", so the speaker could not know who they were without the missing truth. Duffy's readers lose their compassion; Agard's speaker almost lost a self.
Both poems contain witnesses who carry the truth. Duffy's photographer is haunted by it. In the darkroom, a stranger's features "faintly start to twist" as a photograph develops, "a half-formed ghost", and he remembers the cries of the man's wife. His hands did not tremble when he took the picture but seem to now, as the truth catches up with him. Agard's speaker becomes a witness too, telling the stories the curriculum left out. Mary Seacole, "a healing star / among the wounded", is herself a witness to suffering, a figure who, like the photographer, went where the dying were.
Both poets connect truth with light emerging from darkness. The photographer works by the red glow of the darkroom, like a priest in a church, and the images slowly appear. Agard moves from blindness to vision, from the bandaged eye to Toussaint as a beacon. In each case truth has to be developed or uncovered; it does not simply arrive.
Form reflects each poet's attitude. Duffy's four regular six-line stanzas, with their steady rhymes, mirror the photographer's professional control, his spools set out in ordered rows, but the final couplet's rhyme of 'where' and 'care' lands bitterly on indifference. Agard's structure enacts a correction: each roman stanza reports what 'Dem' told, then turns on "dem never tell me" to insert what was missing, and the italic stanzas give the missing truth more space than the official version.
The endings are opposite. Duffy's poem ends with the photographer in an aeroplane, staring impassively, and with the bitter judgement that 'they' do not care, so the truth seems powerless. Agard's speaker ends by taking responsibility for the truth: "I checking out me own history" and "I carving out me identity". The present continuous shows an active, continuing search.
Context explains each poet's anger. Duffy's poem appeared in Standing Female Nude (1985); it names real places of conflict, Belfast and Beirut among them, and by showing such photographs ending up in a Sunday supplement read at leisure, she questions what they achieve. Agard grew up in British Guiana under British rule, taught a history that centred British heroes, so for him the truth about Caribbean and African history is a matter of justice and selfhood.
In conclusion, both poems show truth being edited and ignored by those who control it. Duffy presents a witness whose truth fails to move a comfortable public; Agard presents a speaker who refuses a selected truth and goes looking for the whole one. One poem mourns the truth's weakness; the other shows its power to remake a person.