Remind yourself of 'England in 1819' by Percy Bysshe Shelley in your AQA anthology.
Compare how poets present a moment in British history in 'England in 1819' and in one other poem from 'Worlds and lives'.
Model answer
Both 'England in 1819' and James Berry's 'On an Afternoon Train from Purley to Victoria, 1955' carry a year in their titles, and both capture a moment in British history. But the moments are of very different kinds. Shelley's is a moment of national crisis, the year of the Peterloo Massacre, and his sonnet puts the whole power structure of England on trial. Berry's is a small, private encounter between a Jamaican migrant and a white Quaker woman on a suburban train, yet it reveals the attitudes of post-war Britain as clearly as any public event. Shelley records history through accusation; Berry through conversation.
The titles announce these different scales. 'England in 1819' sounds like the heading of a report on the state of the nation, and the poem delivers exactly that, moving from the king to the princes, the rulers, the people, the army, the laws, religion and parliament. Berry's title is precise and ordinary: a particular afternoon, a particular journey into London. History, for Berry, is found not in palaces and parliaments but in what passes between two strangers.
Both poems show a Britain divided. Shelley's division is between rulers who "neither see nor feel nor know" and a people "starved and stabbed", with an army of "liberticide" between them. Berry's division is subtler, a gap of understanding. The woman is sincere in her belief in "racial brotherhood", yet her question about which part of Africa Jamaica is in exposes how little she knows. The speaker's ironic reply, placing Ireland near Lapland, answers ignorance with humour rather than anger. Shelley's Britain is split by power; Berry's by assumption.
Silence and speech mark both moments. Shelley's protest could not safely be printed, so his poem was itself a kind of silenced speech. Berry's Quaker was "moved in silence" to speak her poem aloud, and the speaker, twice falling thoughtful, shows that the conversation has stirred something he does not say directly. Instead, he sees "empty city streets" alongside his father's banana field: a vision that joins London and Jamaica, present and past. History in Berry's poem lives in memory and migration.
Each poem looks beyond its moment, but differently. Shelley's institutions are "graves" from which "a glorious Phantom" may rise, a vision of a transformed future. Berry's poem ends without resolution: "So sincere she was beautiful", as people sat down around them. His reply that "Snow falls elsewhere", when she wonders why anyone would leave a sunny country, hints at reasons for migration she cannot see, and the final image both joins the two travellers and separates them from everyone else. Shelley's history points to revolution; Berry's records an ambivalent connection.
Form suits each kind of history. Shelley compresses the nation into a single, breathless sentence within a sonnet, turning a love form into a political weapon. Berry's free verse records dialogue without speech marks, in plain, everyday language, so the poem feels like a faithful record of what was said. Its short, irregular stanzas move through the conversation like stops on the journey.
Context is essential to both moments. In 1819 cavalry charged a peaceful crowd at St Peter's Field in Manchester that had gathered to demand parliamentary reform; Shelley, in Italy, responded with a poem that could not be published until 1839. In 1955 Caribbean migrants like Berry, who was born in Jamaica and settled in London in the 1940s as part of the Windrush generation, often met curiosity, ignorance and prejudice, even from people who meant well. The woman's Quaker faith, centred on equality, makes her both sincere and unaware.
Both poems, then, show that history is made of how a nation treats its people. Shelley captures a moment of open injustice and dreams of change; Berry captures a moment of half-understanding and leaves the reader to decide what the future of that relationship will be.