Remind yourself of 'War Photographer' by Carol Ann Duffy in your AQA anthology.
Compare how poets present death in 'War Photographer' and in one other poem from 'Power and conflict'.
Model answer
Both 'War Photographer' and 'Exposure' are haunted by death in war, but each finds it in a different place. Owen, writing as a soldier in the trenches, shows men dying slowly as they freeze and wait in a war that seems to have no purpose. Duffy, writing through the eyes of a photographer, shows the deaths of civilians, and then adds a further horror: the indifference of people at home to the images of the dead. Both poets refuse to make death glorious, and both expose deaths that others do not see.
Those who die are different. Owen's are soldiers: men whose "brains ache" in the "merciless iced east winds that knive us", who cringe in holes and drowse towards death. Duffy's are civilians: a dying man and his wife's "cries", and the "running children in a nightmare heat" who may be next. Owen shows death coming to those sent to fight; Duffy shows it inflicted on those who never chose to be part of a war.
Faces of the dead appear in both poems. Owen's burying-party pause over "half-known faces", and "All their eyes are ice" - a frozen, haunting image of men who were once comrades. Duffy's photograph develops into "A stranger's features", which "faintly start to twist", the face of a man who has died. The words "half-known" and "A stranger's" express the same terrible anonymity of death in war: the dead become faces that can barely be recognised.
Both poets question whether war has any meaning, and both use religious language to do so. Owen's soldiers fear that "love of God seems dying", and the poem asks bluntly, "What are we doing here?" Duffy's photographer works like "a priest" in a church-like darkroom, yet the biblical "All flesh is grass" offers no comfort, only a reminder of mortality. In both poems religion seems unable to redeem the suffering.
Nature and weather shape death differently. In Owen's poem nature itself is the killer: snow comes with "fingering stealth" to feel for the soldiers' faces, and frost will "fasten on this mud and us". Duffy's deaths are caused by people: fields that "explode" beneath children's feet. In England, by contrast, she writes of "simple weather" that can ease ordinary pain, so the benign climate of home sharpens the horror abroad.
Home brings a further horror in both poems. Owen's soldiers drift into dreams of home, but "on us the doors are closed", and so "We turn back to our dying". Duffy's photographer returns home to a country whose tears last only between a bath and a drink, and the poem ends "they do not care". In Owen's poem home is closed to the soldiers; in Duffy's, home closes its mind to the suffering.
Form makes the horror felt. Owen's long lines, pararhymes such as "silent" and "salient", and the refrain "But nothing happens" create an exhausting, unresolved rhythm that matches the endless waiting. Duffy's regular ABBCDD stanzas impose order on horror, like the "ordered rows" of spools in the darkroom, and that order makes the indifference at the end more chilling.
Context explains these perspectives. Owen fought on the Western Front and wrote from his experience of the trenches in winter; he was killed in November 1918, a week before the Armistice. Duffy wrote in 1985, inspired by her friendship with war photographers, and named Belfast, Beirut and Phnom Penh, places of conflict in her own time. Owen writes as a participant who died in the war; Duffy writes as an observer of observers, concerned with how war is seen.
Both poets present death in war as something that degrades and destroys human beings. For Owen, it is the slow, purposeless death of soldiers; for Duffy, it is both the death of the innocent and the failure of those at home to care.