Remind yourself of 'A Century Later' by Imtiaz Dharker in your AQA anthology.
Compare how poets present violence in 'A Century Later' and in one other poem from 'Worlds and lives'.
Model answer
Both 'England in 1819' and 'A Century Later' expose violence committed by the powerful against the powerless, and both end by imagining that the violence will produce its own reversal. They differ in scale and tone. Shelley attacks a whole society whose rulers, army, laws and church starve and kill its people; Dharker focuses on one act of violence against one girl. Shelley's response is furious accusation; Dharker's is a scornful defiance that turns the victim into the victor.
Each poet presents violence through the bodies it harms. Shelley's central image is of "A people starved and stabbed": the alliterating plosives land like blows, and the two verbs join slow suffering to sudden attack. Dharker narrows the focus to one body. "Here is the target" is followed by close-up details of the girl's skin and cheek, so that the noun shows how violence dehumanises its victim, turning a child into something to aim at. Shelley's victims are a nameless mass; Dharker's is an individual whose youth makes the attack shocking.
Both poets show that the violence comes from those who should protect. Shelley lists the guilty: a king who is "old, mad, blind, despised", princes who cling "leechlike" to their country, and an army made "a two-edged sword" by "liberticide", the killing of liberty. Even the law is murderous: the "Golden and sanguine" laws "tempt and slay", with gold suggesting wealth and sanguine the colour of blood. Dharker never names the attackers, but her girl is "Surrendered, surrounded", as if handed over by people who failed to defend her. In both poems, violence is not random but built into the world the victims live in.
The poets differ in how directly they show violence at work. Shelley's poem is a catalogue of accusations rather than a scene, and its anger builds through relentless accumulation. Dharker describes the shooting plainly, then refuses to let it succeed. The girl walks on, and the bullet that "cuts / a pathway in her mind" leads not to death but to an orchard in bloom. Where Shelley shows violence destroying a people, Dharker shows it failing to destroy a mind.
Both poems turn at the end towards a hope that rises out of violence. Shelley's twelve lines of corruption are revealed to be "graves" from which "a glorious Phantom may" "Burst, to illumine our tempestuous day". The Phantom could be liberty or revolution, and light breaking through a storm suggests coming change, though the modal verb keeps it uncertain. Dharker's hope is certain. The girl tells the bullet "You have failed", and in the final stanza the schoolgirls rise to take their places on "the front line". Violence intended to silence one girl has raised an army.
Form reinforces the contrast. Shelley turns the sonnet, a form associated with love, into a single furious sentence: the list of subjects piles up for twelve lines before the main verb finally arrives, so the reader feels the weight of England's corruption before the turn. Dharker's free verse uses short stanzas and enjambment, carrying the girl past the shot across a stanza break, so that the structure itself refuses to stop.
Context explains each poet's anger. Shelley wrote in 1819 in response to the Peterloo Massacre, when cavalry charged a crowd gathered in Manchester to demand political reform; the people starved and stabbed in an untilled field recall that slaughter. Dharker's girl can be read as Malala Yousafzai, shot in the head by a Taliban gunman in 2012 for campaigning for girls' education, and the poem's publication a century after the First World War places her among generations of young people harmed by violence. Both poets see violence as a weapon used against ideas: reform in Shelley's England, education in Dharker's poem.
Both poets, then, present violence as an abuse of power that ultimately undermines itself. Shelley can only prophesy that a Phantom may burst from the graves; Dharker shows the bullet's failure happening, as one girl's survival brings others to their feet.