Remind yourself of 'Lines Written in Early Spring' by William Wordsworth in your AQA anthology.
Compare how poets present criticism of society in 'Lines Written in Early Spring' and in one other poem from 'Worlds and lives'.
Model answer
'Lines Written in Early Spring' and 'England in 1819' are both Romantic poems that criticise the society of their time, but they do so in strikingly different voices. Wordsworth's criticism is quiet, general and sorrowful: he contrasts nature's harmony with "What man has made of man" without naming a single culprit. Shelley's is furious and specific: he names the king, the princes, the army, the law, the church and parliament, and condemns each in turn. Wordsworth laments; Shelley accuses. Yet both end by looking towards a power beyond human corruption that might set things right.
The targets of their criticism reveal the difference. Wordsworth's "man" is all humanity, and the repetition in his key line suggests that people are both the authors and the victims of their condition. Shelley's poem is a list of institutions. The king is "blind" and "dying", the princes are the "dregs" of a "dull" family line, the army is a "two-edged sword", the laws are "Golden and sanguine", religion is "Christless, Godless" and parliament is "Time's worst statute, unrepealed". The insults build with each item. Wordsworth's general grief invites reflection; Shelley's catalogue demands anger.
Their imagery comes from opposite sources. Wordsworth uses the beauty of nature as his measure: flowers that enjoy the air, birds whose smallest movement is "a thrill of pleasure", and "Nature's holy plan". The joy of the grove makes human failure look unnatural. Shelley's imagery is of filth, disease and blood. The princes are compared to mud flowing from a muddy source, and the rulers cling like leeches to their "fainting country" until they fall, "blind in blood, without a blow". England itself becomes a body being drained. Where Wordsworth shows what society should be, Shelley shows what it has become.
Both poets suggest that their society cannot see. Wordsworth's speaker notices everything, from the periwinkle's trailing wreaths to the twigs that "spread out their fan", and humbly admits "Their thoughts I cannot measure". Shelley's rulers "neither see nor feel nor know": the triple negative makes their ignorance total, and the king's physical blindness becomes a symbol of a government blind to its people. Perception in Wordsworth is a moral gift; its absence in Shelley is a political crime, and it has a human cost, a people "starved and stabbed".
Structure intensifies each attitude. Wordsworth's six quatrains, with gentle alternate rhyme, move from joy to sorrow, ending on the rhetorical question "Have I not reason to lament", which appeals to the reader's conscience. Shelley subverts the sonnet, a form associated with love. The whole poem is one sentence in which a long list of subjects is held back from its main verb until near the end, when they all turn out to be "graves", so the reader is dragged through every abuse before reaching the verdict. The first six lines repeat just two rhyme sounds, as if the poem cannot escape the corruption it describes.
The endings reach beyond human society, but in different directions. Wordsworth's appeal is to nature and God, wondering whether his belief is "from heaven" sent. Shelley imagines that from these graves "a glorious Phantom" may burst out to "illumine our tempestuous day", a vision of liberty or revolution rising from the death of the old order. The modal "may" and Wordsworth's repeated "If" both keep hope uncertain.
Context explains the contrast in tone. Wordsworth wrote in 1798, and many readers see the violence of revolutionary France and the hardships of industrial change behind his sorrow. Shelley wrote in 1819 in response to the Peterloo Massacre, when cavalry charged a peaceful crowd gathered in Manchester to demand parliamentary reform. George III was old, blind and mentally ill, and his son ruled as Prince Regent, notorious for his extravagance. Shelley's attack was so dangerous that the poem was not published until 1839, long after his death.
Both poems are therefore acts of protest, but they protest differently. Wordsworth's quiet lament asks readers to compare human society with nature and feel ashamed; Shelley's angry sonnet names the guilty and imagines their overthrow. One appeals to the heart, the other to outrage, and together they show the range of the Romantic response to an unjust world.