Remind yourself of 'Homing' by Liz Berry in your AQA anthology.
Compare how poets present the effects of being judged in 'Homing' and in one other poem from 'Worlds and lives'.
Model answer
'Homing' and 'Thirteen' both show people judged by those in authority for something they cannot help, and both explore what that judgement does to them. Berry's relative was judged for a Black Country accent and learned to hide it for a lifetime; Femi's thirteen-year-old is judged by police officers as a suspect, a description rather than a child. In both poems the judgement enters the victim's sense of self. The difference lies in the endings: Berry's speaker overturns the judgement and celebrates what was condemned, while Femi's boy is left facing a future darkened by it.
In both poems the judges are figures who should protect the young. Berry's judgement comes from school: "hours of elocution" and "the teacher's ruler across your legs". Femi's comes from the police, and from a betrayal: one of the officers once spoke at the boy's primary school assembly and told the children they were supernovas. In both, an institution that claims to help - education, the law - becomes a source of harm.
The judgements are presented through the body. Berry's relative is punished physically, the ruler striking a child's legs, and the shame becomes a locked box hidden under a bed. Femi's boy is "cornered", told that he fits "the description of a man", and seen as "powerless - plump"; he watches the officers "cast lots for your organs", an image that echoes the soldiers who cast lots for Christ's clothes and makes the stop feel predatory. Both poems show a young body under the control of adults with power.
Both show the victims trying to protect themselves. Berry's relative hides the accent, letting it out only with family or a taxi driver. Femi's boy smiles and prays that the officer will remember him, and he repeats his age - "Thirteen, you'll tell him: you're thirteen" - in the hope of being believed. Both are forced to manage how they appear, to perform being acceptable. The effect is fear: "fear condenses on your lips", Femi writes, a physical image of dread.
Judgement also decides who is allowed to be heard. In 'Homing' the accent survives only in private moments, overheard by the family on the phone; the public world has taught the relative to keep it out of earshot. In 'Thirteen' the boy does speak, but his words change nothing, because the officers have already decided what he is. In both poems the judged person's own voice is the first thing to be lost.
The endings diverge. Berry's speaker rejects the judgement completely: "I loved its thick drawl", and the final wish to "shout it from the roofs" turns shame into celebration. Femi gives no such release. The poem ends with a teacher's explanation that supernovas are "dying stars" about to become "black holes", so the image of promise becomes an image of collapse, hinting at what repeated judgement may do to the boy's hopes and his view of himself.
Form shapes each effect. Femi writes in the second person and the future tense, so the stop seems inevitable, something that will keep happening, and the reader is placed in the boy's position. Berry addresses the relative in the past tense: the judgement belongs to history, and the speaker is now free to undo it.
Context explains both. Received Pronunciation was long treated as the prestige accent, and regional accents from industrial areas like the Black Country were often taken as signs of a lower class; elocution lessons aimed to remove them. Femi, who moved from Nigeria to London as a child and grew up in Peckham, writes against the background of stop and search and the racial profiling of young Black people.
Both poems show that judgement leaves lasting marks. Berry's poem suggests that those marks can be healed by the next generation's love; Femi's suggests that while the judging continues, the damage is still being done.