Remind yourself of 'Tissue' by Imtiaz Dharker in your AQA anthology.
Compare how poets present the value of human life in 'Tissue' and in one other poem from 'Power and conflict'.
Model answer
Both 'Tissue' and 'Bayonet Charge' ask what a human life is worth when it is set against the large systems that people create. Hughes shows a soldier who, in the terror of a charge, discovers that the grand ideals for which he was sent to fight mean nothing beside his own survival. Dharker affirms the value of human life through a family's careful record of its members and through a vision of building with "living tissue". Hughes shows the value of life revealed by its nearness to death; Dharker shows it revealed by care.
Both poets set the individual against vast systems. Hughes's soldier wonders in what "cold clockwork" of stars and nations he has become the hand pointing at that second: he is a part in a machine of history and politics, as small and replaceable as a cog. Dharker's systems are maps with their borders, receipts that "fly our lives like paper kites", and the "capitals and monoliths" of power. In both poems large structures treat human beings as small parts of something bigger.
Ideals are exposed as hollow in both. In the charge, "King, honour, human dignity, etcetera" are dropped like luxuries: the soldier's patriotic ideals, even dignity itself, become things he cannot afford, and the dismissive last word shows how empty they have become. Dharker criticises "the shapes that pride can make", the grand buildings and systems that express human pride rather than care for people. Both poets suggest that abstractions such as honour and greatness can come to matter more than people, and both reject this.
The poems value the human body in different ways. Hughes's soldier is all body: sweat, "raw-seamed hot khaki", a rifle as numb as a smashed arm, and finally "His terror's touchy dynamite", an image of fear about to explode. His life's value is felt in his desperate wish to survive. Dharker's family record notes each person's height and weight, physical details lovingly preserved, and her poem ends with "your skin", the reader's own body. Hughes shows the body in danger; Dharker shows it held in regard.
The natural world helps to show what life is worth. Hughes's "yellow hare", thrown up by the shot-slashed furrows, crawls in agony with its mouth open in silence: an innocent life destroyed by human conflict, which the soldier simply plunges past. Dharker's natural images are of light and wind, which reveal the fragility of human structures rather than of human bodies, and suggest a gentler way of living.
Names matter too. Hughes's soldier is never named, referred to only in the third person, as if he could be any soldier sent to fight. Dharker's Koran records "the names and histories" of a family, insisting that each person is known and remembered. One poem shows how war makes people anonymous; the other shows how care preserves them as individuals.
Form reflects these attitudes. Hughes's irregular lines, dashes and enjambment enact panic, and the poem lurches from action to a frozen moment of thought and back to action again. Dharker's calm, enjambed quatrains build steadily towards a vision, and the isolated final line places the human body at the poem's centre.
Context explains the difference. 'Bayonet Charge', from Hughes's first collection, The Hawk in the Rain (1957), is set in the First World War, in which his father had fought, a war that sent millions of individuals into machine-like battles. 'Tissue' appeared in The Terrorist at My Table (2006), a collection concerned with conflict and division, in which Dharker insists on the worth of ordinary lives.
Both poets conclude that a human life is worth more than the systems that use it. Hughes's soldier learns this in a moment of terror; Dharker asks us to remember it every day.