How does Delaney explore ideas about honesty and deception in A Taste of Honey?
Write about:
- the secrets characters keep and the lies they tell, and moments of honesty
- how Delaney presents ideas about honesty and deception.
[30 marks]
AO4
Model answer
On the surface, A Taste of Honey is a play of brutal honesty. Helen and Jo say exactly what they think of each other, often cruelly. Yet beneath this frankness Delaney reveals a web of secrets, evasions and lies: about love, money, race, sexuality and even who Jo's father was. I would argue that Delaney presents deception as a response to shame and fear in a judgemental society, and honesty as both painful and necessary.
The mother and daughter's openness is the first thing the audience notices. Their insults are so direct that they are comic, and Helen is disarmingly honest about her own failings, calling herself "a cruel, wicked woman" before anyone else can. Yet even Helen keeps things hidden. She has moved Jo to a new flat without explaining why, and it is Jo who guesses that her mother is running away from someone. When Peter appears, he is clearly surprised to discover that Helen has a teenage daughter, which implies that Helen has kept Jo out of the picture.
Peter is the play's most obvious deceiver. When Jo goes through his wallet and asks about the other photographs, his response, "Which others?", is a comic attempt at innocence, and his joking about "number thirty-eight" barely hides the truth. The audience is not surprised when, by the final scene, he has left Helen for another woman. Delaney uses comedy to expose his dishonesty, inviting the audience to see through him long before Helen does.
Jo, too, keeps secrets, usually out of fear of her mother's mockery. She hides the Boy's ring on a ribbon under her clothes. When Helen asks about her boyfriend, Jo describes his "beautiful brown eyes and curly hair" but says nothing about his colour, even though she has just assured him that her mother is not prejudiced. The dramatic irony is strong: the audience sees what Jo is concealing and suspects that her confidence in Helen is wishful thinking. In Act 2 she does not tell her mother that she is pregnant at all.
Other secrets are kept because the truth would be dangerous. Geof is evasive about why his landlady threw him out, and he will not confirm Jo's teasing guesses about his sexuality. In 1958 sex between men was illegal, so his silence is a means of self-protection, not simply evasion. Delaney herself was writing at a time when every play had to be licensed by the Lord Chamberlain, so the play's own reticence about Geof mirrors his.
The question of Jo's father shows how unreliable the stories people tell about themselves can be. On her wedding day Helen tells Jo that her real father was a man she had a brief affair with while married to a "Puritan", and she describes him in a way that leaves Jo afraid of what she might have inherited. When Jo asks why she did not make up a story, Helen insists that Jo wanted the truth, yet her casual, mocking account leaves the audience unsure how far to trust it. Delaney suggests that Helen's version of the past may be one more performance.
Even kindness can involve deception. Geof secretly contacts Helen about the pregnancy and asks her not to tell Jo, but Jo quickly guesses, and his well-meant secret damages her trust. The final scene is built on a far crueller concealment: after Geof has been pushed out, Helen hides his departure from Jo, so that Jo spends her last moments on stage believing that her friend will return. Delaney gives the audience knowledge that Jo lacks, making the ending painful to watch.
Against these deceptions, Delaney sets moments of painful honesty. Helen's retort that she should have got rid of Jo is devastating because it sounds so frank, and Jo's decision to tell her mother that the baby's father was black is an act of courage that drives Helen out of the room. Honesty in this play rarely brings comfort, but it is never presented as wrong.
In conclusion, Delaney explores honesty and deception as two sides of life in a society that punished people for being different. Her characters lie or stay silent out of shame, fear or self-interest, and the truth usually hurts. Yet the play itself chooses honesty, showing its audience in 1958 lives that polite theatre preferred to keep hidden.