Remind yourself of 'A Wider View' by Seni Seneviratne in your AQA anthology.
Compare how poets present a sense of belonging in Britain in 'A Wider View' and in one other poem from 'Worlds and lives'.
Model answer
Both 'A Wider View' and 'On an Afternoon Train from Purley to Victoria, 1955' explore what it means to belong in Britain, but from very different positions. Berry's speaker, a man from Jamaica travelling through London in 1955, has his belonging questioned by a well-meaning stranger who asks where he is from and confuses Jamaica with Africa. Seneviratne's speaker, walking through present-day Leeds, asserts belonging by tracing a family line back to a great-great-grandad who worked in the city in 1869. In Berry's poem belonging is something others judge; in Seneviratne's it is something the speaker claims from history.
Berry presents a belonging that is warm but uncertain. The Quaker woman's friendly greeting startles the speaker, and she speaks of "racial brotherhood"; the poem allows a real connection between them. Yet her question "Where are you from?" assumes that he must come from somewhere else, and "What part of Africa is Jamaica?" shows how little she knows of him. His dry reply, "Where Ireland is near Lapland", answers ignorance with wit, and "Snow falls elsewhere" quietly corrects her picture of a sunny homeland that only a fool would leave. Belonging here depends on how others see him.
Seneviratne presents belonging as rooted in place and family. The poem begins not with the speaker but with "my great-great-grandad" in the backyard of his house, and the possessive claims him at once. Named landmarks - Marshall's Temple Mill, Tower Works, Neville Street's Dark Arches, the River Aire - root the poem in a real city. When the speaker walks there in the present, the footsteps echo his, and time sweeps the speaker out to meet him: the city itself seems to confirm that the speaker belongs.
Both poems connect belonging with another place or time. Berry's speaker has a sudden vision in which empty city streets merge with "my father's big banana field", so London and Jamaica overlap in his mind, suggesting a double belonging and perhaps homesickness. Seneviratne's poem keeps its gaze on Leeds, but its ending reaches across generations: speaker and ancestor are "anchored" by a shared gaze, and "past and future generations" arc between them. Berry's belonging stretches across an ocean; Seneviratne's across time.
Both poems end with two people together. Berry's woman is "So sincere she was beautiful" as people "sat down around us": the pronoun links speaker and woman, yet the strangers around them suggest how unusual their conversation is. Seneviratne ends with "We stand now", a pronoun that joins the living and the dead. In both, belonging is found in a connection between two people, but Berry's is fragile and public, Seneviratne's timeless and private.
Form suits each kind of belonging. Berry's free verse is conversational, with plain dialogue and no speech marks, so the reader overhears an awkward, tender exchange in short, flat lines that capture both politeness and misunderstanding. Seneviratne's long, enjambed sentences, moving from 1869 to the present, give belonging the weight of history.
Context explains the different positions. Berry was born in Jamaica and moved to England in the 1940s; the poem's date places it in the years when many Caribbean people settled in Britain and met curiosity as well as prejudice. The Quakers' commitment to equality explains the woman's talk of brotherhood, even as her assumptions show its limits. Seneviratne, born and raised in Leeds and of English and Sri Lankan heritage, has written often about identity and heritage; here she anchors her sense of self in the city's industrial past.
Read together, the poems suggest that belonging in Britain can be questioned by others or claimed through history. Berry shows the gentle but real exclusion of being asked where you are from; Seneviratne's poem reads almost like an answer to that question, pointing to generations of roots in a northern English city.