How does Syal present religion and faith in Anita and Me?
Write about:
- the different beliefs and religious practices in the novel
- how Syal presents religion and faith.
[30 marks]
AO4
Model answer
Religion in Anita and Me is less about doctrine than about identity, community and how people treat each other. Syal presents a village where Hindu, Sikh and Christian practices sit side by side, and she contrasts faith that opens people to others with faith that closes them off. Meena does not end the novel with a religion of her own, but she gains a moral seriousness that the most generous believers in the book would recognise.
The Kumars' approach to religion is practical and inclusive. They celebrate Diwali with Indian friends and Christmas like their neighbours, and Mama takes Meena to a gurdwara, a Sikh temple. Syal presents this flexibility as typical of a migrant family making a home: festivals are ways of keeping memory and community alive. Meena's real religious education comes from Auntie Shaila, whose kitchen shrine and talk of karma and reincarnation deeply unsettle the young girl. Auntie Shaila warns Meena that whatever she does in this life will come back to her in the next, an idea that gives Meena's guilt about her lies a frightening cosmic scale.
Syal uses comedy to compare traditions. Auntie Shaila scoffs at the thought of Meena coming home "reciting hymns and what not", describing church as dreary sitting about and dismal organ music. Her irreverence is funny, but it also reverses the usual assumption that the English way is the norm and Indian practice the oddity. To Auntie Shaila, it is Christian worship that looks strange and joyless.
Hindu imagery also gives the women of the novel a language of power. When Mama is angry she resembles Kali, the fierce goddess with many arms, and when Meena faces down Sam's gang she feels that she has "a hundred arms" like the goddess in Auntie Shaila's house. Syal uses these divine comparisons to suggest that faith can be a source of strength, especially for women and for people who feel powerless in a hostile place.
In Tollington's Christian community, Syal contrasts two kinds of believer. Uncle Alan, the young youth leader at the Methodist church, organises charity and tries to steer Sam away from hatred. He insists that people should jolly well "follow whatever religion they choose", a cheerful, open-minded faith that makes room for the Kumars. Mr Ormerod, by contrast, is a devout churchgoer who argues that people in poorer countries need "culture as well, civilisation" rather than practical help. His words echo the missionary attitudes of the British Empire, treating other peoples as inferior. Syal satirises a faith that uses charity to feel superior.
The fete exposes the gap between Christian ideals and village reality. When Reverend Ince announces that the money raised will mend the church roof, the decision suggests a church more concerned with its own building than with the needy. Sam's furious reaction is racist, but his question about what the roof will do for local people is not entirely unfair. Syal shows how institutional religion can fail a struggling community, leaving its anger to be captured by bigotry.
Festivals also mark turning points in Meena's life. On Diwali, the festival of light, she slips away from her family's celebration to follow Anita, first to the fair and then into the grounds of the Big House, where she loses Mama's necklace. She comes home to find Mama in labour with Sunil. The festival that celebrates light overcoming darkness brings new life to the family just as Meena is straying into Anita's darker world, and Syal lets the symbolism speak quietly.
By the end, Meena's moral growth matters more than any creed. She tells the police the truth about Tracey's fall, refusing the revenge she had imagined, and explains that she now believed in change. In a sense, this is the karma Auntie Shaila preached, translated into Meena's own terms: what you do shapes who you become.
In conclusion, Syal presents religion as plural, often comic and deeply bound up with community. She admires faith that is generous, like Uncle Alan's and the Kumars', and criticises faith that excludes, like Mr Ormerod's. Writing about a period when Commonwealth migration was making Britain more religiously diverse, Syal suggests that what matters is not which faith people follow, but whether it makes them kinder.