Compare how poets present feelings of human insignificance in 'Ozymandias' and in one other poem from 'Power and conflict'.
[30 marks]
Ozymandias
I met a traveller from an antique land
Who said: Two vast and trunkless legs of stone
Stand in the desert. Near them on the sand,
Half sunk, a shattered visage lies, whose frown
And wrinkled lip, and sneer of cold command
Tell that its sculptor well those passions read
Which yet survive, stamped on these lifeless things,
The hand that mocked them and the heart that fed;
And on the pedestal these words appear:
'My name is Ozymandias, king of kings:
Look on my works, ye Mighty, and despair!'
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.
Percy Bysshe Shelley
Model answer
'Ozymandias' and 'Extract from The Prelude' are both Romantic poems in which vast natural forces dwarf human beings. In Shelley's sonnet the insignificance belongs to a king, and we observe it with irony from a great distance in time; in Wordsworth's it is felt by the speaker - Wordsworth remembering his own boyhood - in a moment of terror that changes how he sees the world. Shelley presents human insignificance as a political lesson, Wordsworth as a profound personal experience.
Both poems begin with human pride. Ozymandias's is monumental and tyrannical: "My name is Ozymandias, king of kings", he declares, commanding others to "Look on my works" and "despair". The young Wordsworth's pride is innocent but real. He compares himself to a rower "Proud of his skill" heading for a point he has chosen, keeping "an unswerving line", and he dips his oars "lustily" while the boat goes "heaving through the water" like a swan. The simile of the swan suggests grace and confidence, and the language of control ("chosen", "unswerving") shows a boy who believes he is master of the scene. Both pictures of pride prepare for a fall.
In both poems the natural world reveals how small humans are. Shelley's "colossal wreck" might seem huge, but it is surrounded by sands that are "boundless and bare" and "stretch far away"; the alliteration and long vowels of the final line make the desert seem endless beside the broken statue. Wordsworth's mountain grows before the boy's eyes: "a huge peak, black and huge" rears up, and the repetition of "huge" makes it seem to swell as he looks. Personification makes it terrifying: it "Upreared its head", "Towered up" between the boy and the stars, and "Strode after" him "like a living thing". These verbs give the mountain will and movement, so that the boy feels hunted by something far greater than himself.
The poems differ most in how insignificance is felt. Ozymandias feels nothing: he is long dead, and his face lies "Half sunk" in the sand, so the lesson of his smallness is drawn by the speaker and the reader. The tone is cool and ironic, and the blunt "Nothing beside remains" sounds almost satisfied. Wordsworth records fear and guilt from the inside. "With trembling oars I turned" shows his confidence collapsing, and the boy "stole" his way back, a verb that reminds us the trip began as "an act of stealth" in a boat he had taken without asking. For days afterwards "huge and mighty forms" that "do not live / Like living men" trouble his mind, and "No familiar shapes / Remained". The echo of Shelley's "remains" is striking: in both poems, what once seemed solid disappears, leaving emptiness.
Their forms shape these experiences. Shelley compresses his ideas into a sonnet framed as a traveller's story; the king's insignificance is reported at third hand, which itself diminishes him, and the turn after the inscription delivers the judgement suddenly. Wordsworth uses blank verse, the unrhymed iambic pentameter of serious narrative poetry, and long, enjambed sentences that carry us through the experience in sequence: the calm opening, the confident rowing, the sudden appearance of the peak ("When, from behind that craggy steep"), the retreat and the aftermath. His turning point comes with "When", as Shelley's comes with "Nothing": both mark the moment when human power gives way to something greater.
Both poets were Romantics, and both draw on the idea of the sublime, which the philosopher Edmund Burke linked with vastness and terror. Wordsworth's mountain is a classic sublime experience: it fills him with awe and fear, and the poem suggests that Nature herself is teaching him humility, since he set out "led by her". The Prelude, an autobiographical poem about the growth of his mind, was published only after his death, in 1850. Shelley, a younger and more political Romantic, used the vast desert to humble a tyrant, writing in 1817 soon after the fall of Napoleon. For Wordsworth, insignificance leads to inner growth; for Shelley, it is the fate awaiting all who abuse power.
Both poems, then, show human beings reduced by a power far greater than their own. In 'Ozymandias' the reduction is complete and final, a ruler's empire lost in "The lone and level sands"; in 'Extract from The Prelude' it is the beginning of wisdom, as a proud boy learns that the world holds "unknown modes of being" beyond his control.