Remind yourself of 'The Jewellery Maker' by Louisa Adjoa Parker in your AQA anthology.
Compare the ways poets present the contrast between rich and poor lives in 'The Jewellery Maker' and in one other poem from 'Worlds and lives'.
Model answer
Both 'The Jewellery Maker' and 'In a London Drawingroom' examine lives shaped by money, and both suggest, surprisingly, that colour and warmth do not belong to the rich. Parker's jeweller is poor, yet his world is bright and warm, and he creates luxury for wealthier women he will never know. Eliot's speaker looks out from a drawing room, the comfortable sitting room of a prosperous Victorian home, at a city so grey and joyless that comfort seems worthless. Parker sets rich and poor side by side; Eliot implies that in a city like London nobody, rich or poor, truly lives.
The poets place the reader in very different positions. Parker's narration follows the jeweller through his day, so we see the world from a working man's side, and only in the final stanza does he imagine the wealthy women who will wear his work. Eliot's title places us indoors, among the comfortable classes, looking out at the houses opposite. The view is no reward. A wall cuts the sky "Like solid fog", and the speaker finds only "Monotony of surface & of form".
Colour and warmth are the key to the contrast. The jeweller's world glows: a sky as blue as a plate, hot stone, bright dragonflies made of metal. Eliot's London is drained of both: the sky is "yellowed by the smoke", "all is shadow", and the city offers the "lowest rate of colour, warmth & joy". The word rate, like cost in the line before, belongs to the language of money, as if even happiness in London is measured and found cheap. Parker's poor man lives with beauty; Eliot's prosperous observer lives without it.
Both poets use gold and fabric to mark the divide between rich and poor. Parker's jeweller dreams of draping his wife in "fine-spun gold", but she wears a "simple cotton dress" and her only jewellery is "a plain gold band, worn thin". The imagined wearers, "clear-eyed, bird-boned", have smooth skin, untouched by the sun that has wrinkled the wife's. Eliot's gold is hidden: "the golden rays / Are clothed in hemp", as if sunlight were wrapped in coarse sacking. In Parker, gold travels from the poor to the rich; in Eliot, the city's gold is smothered for everyone.
Each poet also shows how wealth separates people. In Parker's poem, the people who will own his work are distant strangers, whereas the jeweller greets his neighbours with a smile. Eliot's city has no community at all: people "glance unmarking at the passers by", and the "cabs, carriages / All closed" carry the better-off shut away from the street while others "hurry on & look upon the ground". Her conclusion is bleak: the world is "one huge prison-house & court" where "men are punished at the slightest cost", a line that suggests the harsh treatment of the poor in Victorian England.
Form reinforces the contrast. Eliot writes in one unbroken block of blank verse, and the enjambment drives the lines forward without rest, mirroring the relentless, hurrying city. Parker's three stanzas move at a calmer pace, slowed by caesuras, and end tenderly on the metal "his hands caress", so that the final warmth belongs to the maker, not the wearer.
Context sharpens both poems. Eliot, the pen name of Mary Ann Evans, moved to London in 1850 and wrote this poem in 1865, when industrial smoke and overcrowding shaped city life and poverty could be punished severely. Parker, of English and Ghanaian heritage, gives dignity to a craftsman whose skill serves wealthier people, exposing an inequality that still exists between makers and buyers.
Both poets, then, question what wealth is worth. Parker shows that a poor life can be rich in beauty and love, though it is denied the luxuries it produces; Eliot shows that comfort means little in a city where colour, warmth and joy have been priced out of existence.