Compare the ways poets present a moment that is remembered in 'Neutral Tones' and in one other poem from 'Love and relationships'.
[30 marks]
Neutral Tones
We stood by a pond that winter day,
And the sun was white, as though chidden of God,
And a few leaves lay on the starving sod;
- They had fallen from an ash, and were grey.
Your eyes on me were as eyes that rove
Over tedious riddles of years ago;
And some words played between us to and fro
On which lost the more by our love.
The smile on your mouth was the deadest thing
Alive enough to have strength to die;
And a grin of bitterness swept thereby
Like an ominous bird a-wing...
Since then, keen lessons that love deceives,
And wrings with wrong, have shaped to me
Your face, and the God-curst sun, and a tree,
And a pond edged with greyish leaves.
Thomas Hardy
Model answer
'Neutral Tones' and 'Eden Rock' are both built around a single scene by water that has stayed fixed in the speaker's memory, and in both a strange white light hangs over it. But the moments remembered could hardly feel more different. Hardy's speaker recalls the day a relationship died, and the memory has hardened into bitterness. Causley's speaker recalls, or imagines, a picnic with young parents, and the memory glows with love, though it is shadowed by death.
Both poets make the remembered moment vivid through precise detail. Hardy records the "pond", the "few leaves" on "the starving sod" and the exact kind of tree, an "ash". Causley's details are domestic and affectionate: the father's suit "Of Genuine Irish Tweed", the mother's "sprigged dress", the milk poured from "an old H.P. sauce bottle" and "tin cups painted blue". Hardy's details are bleak and drained of colour; Causley's are homely and loving. Both show how memory clings to small particulars.
The light in each scene is unearthly, and each poet uses a simile with a religious undertone. Hardy's sun "was white, as though chidden of God", as if heaven itself had rebuked it. Causley's sky whitens "as if lit by three suns", and the mother's hair "takes on the light". The title's allusion to Eden suggests paradise, and the three suns, like "The same three plates", may hint at a family made whole again. White light chills Hardy's scene but blesses Causley's.
Time works differently in the two memories. Hardy's is firmly past - "We stood", "was", "were" - until "Since then" reveals that "keen lessons that love deceives" have reshaped it. The memory has been altered by later experience into a symbol of love's failure. Causley's moment is held in the present tense, "They are waiting for me", and frozen: the parents are "twenty-five" and "twenty-three", and the dog is "Still two years old". "Still" suggests a moment kept perfectly intact, outside time. Hardy's memory has been darkened by time; Causley's has been preserved from it.
The water in each scene carries meaning. Hardy's pond is still and enclosed, like a relationship that has stopped moving, and it returns at the end, "edged with greyish leaves". Causley's parents are across "the drifted stream" on "the other bank", and they beckon "Leisurely", calling that crossing is "not as hard" as feared. Many readers see the stream as the boundary between life and death, so the remembered moment becomes an invitation.
The endings complete the contrast. Hardy's poem circles back to the pond in its final lines, trapping the speaker inside the memory. Causley ends with a single line set apart, in which the speaker admits "I had not thought" that it would be "like this". The line is open and ambiguous, suggesting wonder, or perhaps unease, at the moment of crossing over. Structure matters here: Hardy's four enclosed ABBA quatrains seal the memory, while Causley's quatrains narrow to three lines and then to one, as if the speaker is stepping towards the edge.
Context deepens each poem. Hardy wrote 'Neutral Tones' in 1867 but published it in 1898, so the memory was kept for more than thirty years, just as the speaker keeps it. Causley's father died in 1924, when Causley was seven, from the effects of the First World War, which helps to explain why the father is fixed for ever at a young age, in a moment that can only be revisited in imagination.
In conclusion, both poets show how one moment can be held in memory with extraordinary clarity. For Hardy it is a wound that time has deepened into bitterness; for Causley it is a moment of love preserved by memory, which may also be waiting at the end of life.