Compare how poets present the ways experiences shape identity in 'Extract from The Prelude' and in one other poem from 'Power and conflict'.
[30 marks]
Extract from The Prelude
One summer evening (led by her) I found
A little boat tied to a willow tree
Within a rocky cove, its usual home.
Straight I unloosed her chain, and stepping in
Pushed from the shore. It was an act of stealth
And troubled pleasure, nor without the voice
Of mountain-echoes did my boat move on;
Leaving behind her still, on either side,
Small circles glittering idly in the moon,
Until they melted all into one track
Of sparkling light. But now, like one who rows,
Proud of his skill, to reach a chosen point
With an unswerving line, I fixed my view
Upon the summit of a craggy ridge,
The horizon's utmost boundary; far above
Was nothing but the stars and the grey sky.
She was an elfin pinnace; lustily
I dipped my oars into the silent lake,
And, as I rose upon the stroke, my boat
Went heaving through the water like a swan;
When, from behind that craggy steep till then
The horizon's bound, a huge peak, black and huge,
As if with voluntary power instinct,
Upreared its head. I struck and struck again,
And growing still in stature the grim shape
Towered up between me and the stars, and still,
For so it seemed, with purpose of its own
And measured motion like a living thing,
Strode after me. With trembling oars I turned,
And through the silent water stole my way
Back to the covert of the willow tree;
There in her mooring-place I left my bark, -
And through the meadows homeward went, in grave
And serious mood; but after I had seen
That spectacle, for many days, my brain
Worked with a dim and undetermined sense
Of unknown modes of being; o'er my thoughts
There hung a darkness, call it solitude
Or blank desertion. No familiar shapes
Remained, no pleasant images of trees,
Of sea or sky, no colours of green fields;
But huge and mighty forms, that do not live
Like living men, moved slowly through the mind
By day, and were a trouble to my dreams.
William Wordsworth
Model answer
'Extract from The Prelude' and 'Checking Out Me History' both explore how experiences shape a person's identity, but they show very different experiences and very different selves. For Wordsworth, a single encounter with nature in childhood reshapes his mind, one stage in what his long poem presents as the growth of a poet. For Agard's speaker, identity has been shaped first by an education that imposed someone else's history and then by the discovery of hidden heroes. Wordsworth's identity is formed by nature acting on him; Agard's speaker actively reclaims an identity that others tried to erase.
In both poems the experiences are first imposed from outside. Wordsworth's boy is "led by her" - by Nature - to the boat, and the mountain then confronts him with a power he did not choose to meet: "with purpose of its own", it "Strode after me". Agard's speaker has had an education forced upon them. "Dem tell me", the speaker repeats, and the repetition sounds like rote learning. The metaphors "Bandage up me eye" and "Blind me to me own identity" show that this experience has damaged the speaker's sense of self.
Both poems describe discovery, but of very different things. Wordsworth's experience reveals something mysterious beyond himself: his brain "Worked with a dim and undetermined sense / Of unknown modes of being". He learns that nature has a power and a life he cannot fully understand, and the discovery leaves "a darkness" over his thoughts. Agard's speaker discovers people: Toussaint, "a slave / with vision"; Nanny, a "see-far woman"; Mary Seacole, "a healing star" and "a yellow sunrise / to the dying". Wordsworth's discovery brings darkness and mystery; Agard's brings light and inspiration, as the heroes become beacons for the speaker's own identity.
The way identity emerges differs. Wordsworth's change is gradual and largely passive: for "many days" the "huge and mighty forms" move "slowly through the mind", reshaping his imagination whether he wishes it or not. Agard's speaker takes control. The poem's final lines turn from what "Dem" said to defiant action: the speaker is "checking out me own history" and declares, "I carving out me identity". The present continuous verbs show identity as something actively and continually made, and "carving" suggests effort and permanence, as if the speaker were sculpting a new self.
Voice is itself a sign of identity in both poems. Wordsworth writes in polished, standard English blank verse, the established voice of English poetry, appropriate to an adult poet reflecting on how he became one. Agard writes in a phonetic Caribbean Creole - "Dem", "dat", "de" - with non-standard grammar, so that the speaker's language becomes part of the identity being asserted. The mocking nursery rhymes (a cow that can "jump over de moon") contrast with the chant-like praise of the heroes, so the form dramatises the move from imposed to chosen identity.
Structure traces the change in both. Wordsworth's extract moves from confident pleasure, to terror, to a transformed mind, ending with "a trouble to my dreams": identity unsettled and still developing. Agard's poem alternates between the "Dem tell me" sections and celebrations of forgotten heroes, until the ending replaces "Dem" with 'I'. The movement from "Dem" to 'I' is the shape of an identity being claimed.
Context makes each poet's purpose clear. The Prelude, published after Wordsworth's death in 1850, is subtitled Growth of a Poet's Mind, and episodes like this one are presented as the experiences that made him a poet; for Wordsworth, as a Romantic, nature was the greatest teacher. Agard, born in Guyana in 1949, moved to Britain in the late 1970s, and his poem protests against a curriculum that taught British history while ignoring the history of Black people in the Caribbean and Africa.
In conclusion, both poems show identity being shaped by experience, but they disagree about who holds the power. Wordsworth's identity is formed by nature's overwhelming lessons; Agard's speaker refuses an imposed identity and carves out a new one. One poem shows a mind being shaped; the other shows a person taking charge of the shaping.
Explanation
Strong answers compare who or what shapes identity in each poem (nature, or an imposed education), what is discovered ("unknown modes of being", or forgotten heroes), and how identity emerges (passively, or by "carving" it out). The contrast between Wordsworth's darkness and Agard's imagery of light, and between standard English and Creole, shows perceptive comparison. Avoid retelling the heroes' stories without analysing Agard's language.