Question 1
2 marksThe diagram shows triangle PQR.
Angle QPR = 40°, angle PQR = 60° and PR = 10 cm.
Zara says,
"I used the sine rule and found that QR = 12 cm."
Without working out QR, explain why Zara must be wrong.
Model answer
QR is opposite angle P = 40°, and PR = 10 cm is opposite angle Q = 60°.
In a triangle, the larger angle is opposite the longer side.
40° is smaller than 60°, so QR must be shorter than PR, that is, less than 10 cm.
So QR cannot be 12 cm and Zara must be wrong.
Explanation
The sine rule says each side is proportional to the sine of its opposite angle, and for these angles a bigger angle has a bigger sine. So the side opposite 40° must be shorter than the side opposite 60°. Checking which angle is opposite which side is also the way to spot a wrongly set up sine rule.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for QR is opposite the 40° angle and PR (10 cm) is opposite the 60° angle
Both sides correctly matched to their opposite angles, seen or clearly implied.
-
1 mark
B1 for the smaller angle is opposite the shorter side, so QR must be less than 10 cm (not 12 cm) oe
Accept 'QR = \(\dfrac{10\sin 40^\circ}{\sin 60^\circ}\) and sin 40° is less than sin 60°, so QR is less than 10'. Also accept 'the longest side is PQ, opposite the largest angle 80°, and QR is the shortest side, opposite the smallest angle'. A statement with no link between angle sizes and side lengths scores B0.