Question 1
2 marksThe diagram shows triangles ABC and DEF.
Angle A = angle D = 50°, angle B = angle E = 60° and angle C = angle F = 70°.
Mo says,
"The triangles are congruent, because all three pairs of angles are equal."
Is Mo correct?
Give a reason for your answer.
Model answer
No. Having all three angles equal shows that the triangles are the same shape (they are similar), but they can be different sizes. To prove congruence, at least one pair of corresponding sides must be equal (for example ASA). In the diagram, triangle DEF is clearly larger than triangle ABC.
Explanation
AAA is not a congruence condition: an enlargement has the same angles as the original but different side lengths. The congruence conditions are SSS, SAS, ASA (or AAS) and RHS, and each one includes at least one pair of equal sides.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for No
'No' on its own scores B1 only if followed by a correct reason; 'Yes' scores 0.
-
1 mark
B1 for a correct reason, e.g. equal angles only show the triangles are the same shape (similar), not the same size; congruence needs at least one pair of corresponding sides to be equal
Accept 'AAA is not a condition for congruence', 'the triangles could be different sizes', 'one is an enlargement of the other'. Do not accept 'the angles are in different places' or 'the triangles look different' alone.