Question 1
2 marksCylinder A has radius 3 cm and height 5 cm.
Cylinder B has radius 6 cm and height 12 cm.
Jamal says,
'Cylinder B is bigger in every direction, so the two cylinders are mathematically similar.'
Is Jamal correct?
Show how you decide.
Model answer
Radius: \(6 \div 3 = 2\)
Height: \(12 \div 5 = 2.4\)
For the cylinders to be similar, every length must be multiplied by the same scale factor. 2 ≠ 2.4, so Jamal is not correct.
(B would need a height of \(5 \times 2 = 10\) cm.)
Explanation
Mathematically similar shapes have all corresponding lengths in the same ratio. Being bigger in every direction is not enough: the radius has been doubled but the height multiplied by 2.4, so B is a differently shaped cylinder.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for \(6 \div 3 = 2\) and \(12 \div 5 = 2.4\) oe
Or comparing ratios such as 3 : 5 and 6 : 12 (= 3 : 6), or showing a height of 10 cm would be needed for similarity.
-
1 mark
B1 for No, the scale factors are different
'No' with no valid comparison scores 0.