Question 1
1 markA stone is dropped from the top of a cliff.
The graph shows the distance, d metres, it has fallen after t seconds.
Ravi says,
"The graph goes through the origin, so d is directly proportional to t."
Is Ravi correct?
Give a reason for your answer.
Model answer
No. For direct proportion the graph must be a straight line through the origin. This graph passes through the origin but it is a curve (when t doubles from 1 to 2, d goes from 5 to 20, which is 4 times as far).
Explanation
A graph shows direct proportion only when it is a straight line and passes through the origin: both conditions are needed. Here the stone speeds up, so the distance grows faster than the time and the graph curves upwards. In fact d is proportional to \(t^2\), not to t.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for No, with a correct reason, e.g. the graph is a curve, not a straight line
oe, e.g. 'when t doubles from 1 to 2, d goes from 5 to 20, so it does not double'; do not accept 'No' with no reason or an incorrect reason