Question 1
1 markThe pie charts show how the students at two schools, A and B, travel to school.
Ella says,
"More students walk to school at School A than at School B, because the Walk sector for School A is bigger."
Is Ella correct?
Give a reason for your answer.
Model answer
Ella is not necessarily correct. The pie charts only show the proportion of students who walk at each school. We do not know how many students are at each school, so if School B is much bigger, more students could walk there.
Explanation
A bigger sector means a bigger proportion of that school, not more students. To compare actual numbers you need the total for each pie chart. This is a common way that pie charts are misread.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for No (or 'you cannot tell'), because the pie charts show proportions, not numbers, and the numbers of students at the two schools are not known
oe, e.g. 'School B might have more students'