'The greatest strength of the Persian army was its size.'
To what extent do you agree with this view?
Spelling, punctuation and grammar and the use of specialist terminology will be assessed in this answer
Model answer
The size of the Persian army was a real strength, but it was not its greatest one: its organisation, its archers and cavalry, and its engineering and supply were more important, and size could even become a weakness.
There is no doubt that size mattered. Herodotus says Xerxes' land army contained 1,700,000 infantry and 80,000 cavalry. Modern historians think this is hugely exaggerated, but even a much smaller figure would have made it the largest army the Greeks had ever seen. Its size frightened many Greek states into giving earth and water: Thessaly and Thebes medised and Argos stayed neutral. Numbers allowed Xerxes to send wave after wave against the pass at Thermopylae and to occupy central Greece and Athens. After Salamis Mardonius could still keep a large picked force in Greece.
Yet size also caused problems. Feeding the army was difficult: Herodotus says it drank rivers dry and ruined the cities that had to feed it, and on the retreat in 480 BC many died of hunger and disease. In narrow places numbers were no help. At Thermopylae Herodotus says the Persians could not use their superior numbers, and at Salamis the fleet was crowded in the straits so that ships crashed into each other.
The army had other important strengths. Its organisation was impressive: units of ten, a hundred, a thousand and ten thousand under Persian commanders, with each nation fighting with its own weapons. The Immortals were a picked force of ten thousand, kept at full strength. Persian archers were feared; at Thermopylae, according to a famous Greek story, their arrows could hide the sun. The cavalry was dangerous in open country: at Plataea the Persian horsemen, at first under Masistius, harassed the Greeks and later fouled their water supply. Engineering and logistics - the Athos canal, the Hellespont bridges and the supply depots - got the army to Greece at all. Tactical skill also counted: Thermopylae was won by sending the Immortals round the mountain by night.
We should also remember that Herodotus' enormous figures belong to the Greek story of a vast barbarian host defeated by a few free men, so the army's size may have been exaggerated precisely to make the Greek victory seem greater.
These strengths were greatest when they worked together. The army's size mattered because the empire's organisation could gather, feed and move it, and because archers and cavalry could use it on open ground. Where those conditions were missing, as in close combat against hoplites, numbers counted for little.
Overall, I disagree with the statement. Size gave the Persian army its reputation and frightened many Greeks into submission, but its greatest strength was the organisation of the empire that raised, supplied and commanded it, together with its archers and cavalry. Without these, its size would have been a burden.
Explanation
Strong essays consider several strengths with evidence (organisation, the Immortals, archers, cavalry, engineering and supply) and show how size could be a weakness, for example in supply and at Thermopylae and Salamis. One-sided answers that only praise the numbers are capped at 12.