'Alexander genuinely believed that he was a god.'
How far do you agree with this view?
You must use and analyse the ancient sources you have studied as well as supporting your answer with your own knowledge.
Model answer
Alexander certainly encouraged the idea that he was more than human, but I do not think the sources prove that he believed he was a god in the full sense.
There is evidence that he believed in his divine birth. Plutarch records stories of a thunderbolt striking Olympias and of a snake beside her, and says Olympias told Alexander the 'secret' of his birth before he left for Asia. After his visit to the oracle of Ammon at Siwa, he is said to have prayed before Gaugamela that the gods should help the Greeks 'if he was really sprung from Zeus'. Arrian reports that he wanted men to prostrate themselves before him 'as to a god', believing Ammon rather than Philip was his father, and in 327 BC he tried to introduce proskynesis. Cleitus mocked him for disowning Philip to call himself son of Ammon, which suggests the claim was taken seriously.
However, these sources must be used carefully. Plutarch's prayer comes from Callisthenes, the court historian whose job was to glorify Alexander; according to Arrian, Callisthenes even boasted that Alexander's divinity depended on what he wrote. Arrian's report about prostration is introduced as a 'current report', not a fact, and Plutarch's birth stories are introduced with 'we are told'. So much of the evidence may reflect propaganda rather than Alexander's private beliefs.
Other evidence suggests he used divinity as a political tool. Arrian, who admired Alexander and had studied the best sources, thought his claim to divine birth might have been 'a device to make his subjects respect him'. When the Macedonians opposed proskynesis, Alexander quickly dropped it for them, which looks calculated. After killing Cleitus, Arrian says, he admitted that he had done wrong, as a mere man would. He also sacrificed constantly to the gods, for example to Heracles at Tyre, behaving as a pious mortal. Being the son of Zeus, like Heracles, was different from being a god. Arrian reports that when Hephaestion died, Alexander asked Ammon whether his friend could be worshipped as a god and accepted the answer that he could not, which shows respect for the god's authority.
The coins showing Alexander with the ram's horns of Ammon, minted by Lysimachus and Ptolemy I, show that he was worshipped after his death, but they were made by successors who wanted to link their own rule to him, so they tell us little about what Alexander himself believed.
Overall, Alexander probably believed he was the son of Zeus Ammon and favoured by the gods, but the evidence that he thought himself a god is weaker and comes mainly from hostile reports and propaganda. He used the idea of divinity when it helped him rule.
Explanation
Top answers distinguish between believing he was son of a god and believing he was a god, and evaluate the evidence: Callisthenes' propaganda behind Plutarch 33, Arrian's hearsay and his defence in 7.29, and the posthumous purpose of the coins. Narratives of Siwa and proskynesis without source evaluation are capped at 8.